Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
Moderators: Coyote, nebugeater, Brad, Omaha Cowboy, BRoss
-
- Planning Board
- Posts: 2743
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 3:00 pm
- Location: Metro Detroit Michigan
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
There were other renderings that looked better...like daytime.
- skinzfan23
- City Council
- Posts: 9200
- Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 11:26 am
- Location: Omaha/Bellevue
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
I sometimes wonder about this as well. I think it would have set a precedent and created a different vibe away from the suburban looking hotels that were all built in North Downtown.RNcyanide wrote:I feel like it would have set an entirely different vibe in North Downtown. Buildings would be taller, more interesting things would be down there, the crappy suburban hotels would have been done differently, etc.Midwestern wrote:I'd still much rather have that than the Hilton though...
-
- Planning Board
- Posts: 2743
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 3:00 pm
- Location: Metro Detroit Michigan
Marriott
This horse is just as dead now as it was in 2003 but I've got to tilt at windmills one more time...Brad wrote:Capitol District last night from the Helicopter:
IF the hotel chosen by Hal Daub (the highrise) had been built look at all the land that could have been developed. Yes, yes, yes, it's also a height thing but take a look at the picture. The amount of land that the Hilton takes up is obscene. And 800 room hotel, or even the 525 room one that was proposed could have been 20-30 or more floors. And if the 525 room one was built and an expansion was warranted, as was the case, a shorter addition could have been built.
Just lamenting....
- PotatoeEatsFish
- Human Relations
- Posts: 749
- Joined: Wed Jul 22, 2015 11:59 pm
Re: Official: Capitol District
The Great Wall of Hilton annoys me to no end.NovakOmaha wrote:This horse is just as dead now as it was in 2003 but I've got to tilt at windmills one more time...Brad wrote:Capitol District last night from the Helicopter:
IF the hotel chosen by Hal Daub (the highrise) had been built look at all the land that could have been developed. Yes, yes, yes, it's also a height thing but take a look at the picture. The amount of land that the Hilton takes up is obscene. And 800 room hotel, or even the 525 room one that was proposed could have been 20-30 or more floors. And if the 525 room one was built and an expansion was warranted, as was the case, a shorter addition could have been built.
Just lamenting....
#SaveTheUglyGrainSilos2024
- Coyote
- City Council
- Posts: 33088
- Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2003 11:18 am
- Location: Aksarben Village
- Contact:
Re: Official: Capitol District
Does anyone remember the politics behind that decision? Who benefited the most in that decision?
Re: Official: Capitol District
To lessen the burden on tax payers:Coyote wrote:Does anyone remember the politics behind that decision? Who benefited the most in that decision?
http://www.eomahaforums.com/viewtopic.p ... it=Mariott
Omaha Skyline Photos, Omaha Aerial Photos, and More.
Website: www.bradwilliamsphotography.com
Facebook: www.facebook.com/bradwilliamsphotography
Twitter: www.twitter.com/bradwphoto
Instagram: www.instagram.com/bradwilliamsphotography
YouTube: www.youtube.com/@bradwilliamsphoto
Re: Official: Capitol District
I seem to remember Fahey calling Hilton more "Union-friendly" than Mariott. I remember him using that as one of his deciding factors.Brad wrote:To lessen the burden on tax payers:Coyote wrote:Does anyone remember the politics behind that decision? Who benefited the most in that decision?
http://www.eomahaforums.com/viewtopic.p ... it=Mariott
-
- Planning Board
- Posts: 2743
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 3:00 pm
- Location: Metro Detroit Michigan
Re: Official: Capitol District
I want to say is was out of spite against Hal Daub. Also it was cheaper & of course that always plays into it. The proposed Marriot was 525 rooms & the wisdom was that 400 rooms would be just fine.edsas wrote:I seem to remember Fahey calling Hilton more "Union-friendly" than Mariott. I remember him using that as one of his deciding factors.Brad wrote:To lessen the burden on tax payers:Coyote wrote:Does anyone remember the politics behind that decision? Who benefited the most in that decision?
http://www.eomahaforums.com/viewtopic.p ... it=Mariott
-
- Planning Board
- Posts: 2743
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 3:00 pm
- Location: Metro Detroit Michigan
Re: Official: Capitol District
I want to say is was out of spite against Hal Daub. Also it was cheaper & of course that always plays into it. The proposed Marriot was 525 rooms & the wisdom was that 400 rooms would be just fine.edsas wrote:I seem to remember Fahey calling Hilton more "Union-friendly" than Mariott. I remember him using that as one of his deciding factors.Brad wrote:To lessen the burden on tax payers:Coyote wrote:Does anyone remember the politics behind that decision? Who benefited the most in that decision?
http://www.eomahaforums.com/viewtopic.p ... it=Mariott
I found a picture from way back when. This would have made such a different vibe.
Re: Official: Capitol District
Honestly the height is the only thing I like about the Marriott proposal. That's way too industrial of a look.
When fortune smiles on something as violent and ugly as revenge, it seems proof like no other that not only does God exist, you're doing his will.
The Bride
The Bride
Re: Official: Capitol District
We gotta stop talking about this tower.
-
- Library Board
- Posts: 433
- Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 3:57 pm
- Location: Omaha Metro Area
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
The deal was Daub picked the winner as a lame duck after losing the election. Fahey changed it out of spite or other reasons.
The cynic in me would suggest picking one group over another could be lucrative for a politician, in legal campaign contributions or possible in post mayoral jobs or contracts or deals, even in illegal cash. I am not accusing anyone of anything but building one hotel instead of another has to be worth a lot of money to the groups involved.
The cynic in me would suggest picking one group over another could be lucrative for a politician, in legal campaign contributions or possible in post mayoral jobs or contracts or deals, even in illegal cash. I am not accusing anyone of anything but building one hotel instead of another has to be worth a lot of money to the groups involved.
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
That pic looks like it came out of The Great Gatsby.NovakOmaha wrote:I want to say is was out of spite against Hal Daub. Also it was cheaper & of course that always plays into it. The proposed Marriot was 525 rooms & the wisdom was that 400 rooms would be just fine.edsas wrote:I seem to remember Fahey calling Hilton more "Union-friendly" than Mariott. I remember him using that as one of his deciding factors.Brad wrote:To lessen the burden on tax payers:Coyote wrote:Does anyone remember the politics behind that decision? Who benefited the most in that decision?
http://www.eomahaforums.com/viewtopic.p ... it=Mariott
I found a picture from way back when. This would have made such a different vibe.
- Omaha Cowboy
- The Don
- Posts: 1013179
- Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2004 5:31 am
- Location: West Omaha
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
There are other renderings of this proposed hotel that make it look a bit more reserved than this one.. But indeed, it would have been an impressive development for Omaha.. Anyone who remembers my imput at the time from the old Omaha Chamber Forum (several years before this forum was created) back in 2001, will recall my profound disappointment when Fahey was elected and promptly shelved Daub's hotel..then proposed what we now know is the downtown Omaha Hilton.. But, friends, that was 15 years ago.. I've moved on. Certainly we've seen other highrise disappointments- The Wallstreet Tower debacle and recently, HDR pulling the plug on their downtown HQ's.. I agree with Novak that this Marriott, if built, would have given the area surrounding the arena and north downtown a different, perhaps more positive vibe..choke wrote:That pic looks like it came out of The Great Gatsby.NovakOmaha wrote:I want to say is was out of spite against Hal Daub. Also it was cheaper & of course that always plays into it. The proposed Marriot was 525 rooms & the wisdom was that 400 rooms would be just fine.edsas wrote:I seem to remember Fahey calling Hilton more "Union-friendly" than Mariott. I remember him using that as one of his deciding factors.Brad wrote:To lessen the burden on tax payers:Coyote wrote:Does anyone remember the politics behind that decision? Who benefited the most in that decision?
http://www.eomahaforums.com/viewtopic.p ... it=Mariott
I found a picture from way back when. This would have made such a different vibe.
That said.. I've learned over the years, there is a HUGE difference between getting excited over a proposed development vs one which actually breaks ground with tower cranes in the air. At present, I'm thrilled with the Capitol District project and potentially what it will bring to downtown Omaha..as we know for certain, this project WILL become reality and completed in a little more than a year...
Ciao..LiO...Peace
Go Cowboys!
-
- Planning Board
- Posts: 2044
- Joined: Mon Sep 14, 2015 10:03 pm
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
Whoa there, lay off the sane and rationalist propaganda! Let us lament!Omaha Cowboy wrote:
That said.. I've learned over the years, there is a HUGE difference between getting excited over a proposed development vs one which actually breaks ground with tower cranes in the air. At present, I'm thrilled with the Capitol District project and potentially what it will bring to downtown Omaha..as we know for certain, this project WILL become reality and completed in a little more than a year...
Ciao..LiO...Peace
Jokes aside, agreed. But I think that rendering is gorgeous. I'd love to see it or something like it built North Downtown or south a bit to pull the skyline out. (and look like a sexy, sexy building from another city)
- Omaha Cowboy
- The Don
- Posts: 1013179
- Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2004 5:31 am
- Location: West Omaha
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
LOL.. And to your point about a potential building, such as this, pulling the skyline out.. I completely agree ...Athomsfere wrote:Whoa there, lay off the sane and rationalist propaganda! Let us lament!Omaha Cowboy wrote:
That said.. I've learned over the years, there is a HUGE difference between getting excited over a proposed development vs one which actually breaks ground with tower cranes in the air. At present, I'm thrilled with the Capitol District project and potentially what it will bring to downtown Omaha..as we know for certain, this project WILL become reality and completed in a little more than a year...
Ciao..LiO...Peace
Jokes aside, agreed. But I think that rendering is gorgeous. I'd love to see it or something like it built North Downtown or south a bit to pull the skyline out. (and look like a sexy, sexy building from another city)
Ciao..LiO...Peace
Go Cowboys!
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
Found another view of this proposal:
- skinzfan23
- City Council
- Posts: 9200
- Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 11:26 am
- Location: Omaha/Bellevue
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
I also like the enclosed walkway a lot more in that design.
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
I remember how disappointed everyone was when Fahey passed on the high rise Marriott in favor of the Hilton. I remember he started referring to the Hilton as a "mid-rise."
I have absolutely no recollection of Fahey partly justifying the Hilton because it was more union friendly though.....
Greg
I have absolutely no recollection of Fahey partly justifying the Hilton because it was more union friendly though.....
Greg
-
- Planning Board
- Posts: 2743
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 3:00 pm
- Location: Metro Detroit Michigan
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
One other thing about this design. Think of the land that would have been free for other development rather the current design needing so much more land for rooms.
-
- Library Board
- Posts: 433
- Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 3:57 pm
- Location: Omaha Metro Area
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
There would have still been a parking garage behind the Marriott. I don't know if you would have gotten more land back.NovakOmaha wrote:One other thing about this design. Think of the land that would have been free for other development rather the current design needing so much more land for rooms.
-
- Planning Board
- Posts: 2743
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 3:00 pm
- Location: Metro Detroit Michigan
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
The Des Moines downtown Marriott packs 417 rooms and all the first class amenities into 33 floors with a parking garage and takes up a half block, approx 300X150. Tossing on a few more floors and a few more rooms per floor, with all the required amenities and a parking garage and you'd still have a huge part of that land for another high rise or pretty much any development.Joe_Sovereign wrote:There would have still been a parking garage behind the Marriott. I don't know if you would have gotten more land back.NovakOmaha wrote:One other thing about this design. Think of the land that would have been free for other development rather the current design needing so much more land for rooms.
- Omaha Cowboy
- The Don
- Posts: 1013179
- Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2004 5:31 am
- Location: West Omaha
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
Wow. It's hard for me to go back in time and revisit this proposed development from 2001-
Opportunity lost..
I thought Fahey was such a chump for scrapping this hotel plan (still do).. He originally proposed a ridiculous looking 400 room Hilton.. The design was completely incompatible with the futuristic look of the now CenturyLink Center. After pressure from the city-council and the public, Fahey then had a redesigned Hilton proposal adding 50 rooms. So the Original Hilton was built with a too small 450 rooms (and we had to beg, borrow and steal to get Fahey to add 50 rooms from the initial 400).. So the Hilton we see today, was the Fahey "redesign" adding 50 rooms and thus, the 450 room, still too small Hilton was born (remember the Daub Marriott highrise was designed at 528 rooms).. of course, I said at the time, in 2001, that 450 rooms was too small and that within a 5 or so years, the city would have to add more rooms to have any sort of competitive edge (and at what cost?)..and Viola! In 2011, 150 rooms were added making the Hilton its current 600 rooms (and at an extra inflated cost)..
It was ego driven, short sightedness by Fahey.. Had he built the original Daub highrise Marriott, and perhaps enhanced the 528 room total to 550-600, the higher cost of the 2011 Hilton expansion would not have been necessary..
Sigh..
In any case, I am very pleased with the Capitol District 330 room Marriott development.. This makes nearly 1000 hotel rooms (930) within an easy walk from CenturyLink.. This puts Omaha in a much more competitive bracket when attempting to attract revenue rich conventions to the city..
I just think it's unfortunate we had to take a long, costly alternative route to finally make this happen...
Ciao..LiO...Peace
Opportunity lost..
I thought Fahey was such a chump for scrapping this hotel plan (still do).. He originally proposed a ridiculous looking 400 room Hilton.. The design was completely incompatible with the futuristic look of the now CenturyLink Center. After pressure from the city-council and the public, Fahey then had a redesigned Hilton proposal adding 50 rooms. So the Original Hilton was built with a too small 450 rooms (and we had to beg, borrow and steal to get Fahey to add 50 rooms from the initial 400).. So the Hilton we see today, was the Fahey "redesign" adding 50 rooms and thus, the 450 room, still too small Hilton was born (remember the Daub Marriott highrise was designed at 528 rooms).. of course, I said at the time, in 2001, that 450 rooms was too small and that within a 5 or so years, the city would have to add more rooms to have any sort of competitive edge (and at what cost?)..and Viola! In 2011, 150 rooms were added making the Hilton its current 600 rooms (and at an extra inflated cost)..
It was ego driven, short sightedness by Fahey.. Had he built the original Daub highrise Marriott, and perhaps enhanced the 528 room total to 550-600, the higher cost of the 2011 Hilton expansion would not have been necessary..
Sigh..
In any case, I am very pleased with the Capitol District 330 room Marriott development.. This makes nearly 1000 hotel rooms (930) within an easy walk from CenturyLink.. This puts Omaha in a much more competitive bracket when attempting to attract revenue rich conventions to the city..
I just think it's unfortunate we had to take a long, costly alternative route to finally make this happen...
Ciao..LiO...Peace
Go Cowboys!
-
- Parks & Recreation
- Posts: 1219
- Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2005 12:40 pm
- Contact:
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
The main reason Fahey chose the smaller Hilton was cost; the Hilton was originally bid at $60 million for the 400 rooms versus over $90 million for the 528 room Marriott. The redesigns to the Hilton pushed the final cost of the Hilton to $71 million for 450 rooms. Pretty tough to justify spending the extra $20 million to add 78 rooms...especially when the Hilton added twice as many rooms (150) ten years later at $37 million. (Still a lower cost per room, especially when you consider that the expansion was built with 2011 money instead of 2002 money.)
The only reason people are still upset about this is the obsession by some people for height... the same height obsession that resulted in the dumb selection of the Wall Street Tower boondoggle instead of a midrise office building. Nearly a dozen years later, all we have to show for it is the remnants of a wiffle ball field.
The only reason people are still upset about this is the obsession by some people for height... the same height obsession that resulted in the dumb selection of the Wall Street Tower boondoggle instead of a midrise office building. Nearly a dozen years later, all we have to show for it is the remnants of a wiffle ball field.
-
- Human Relations
- Posts: 662
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2016 7:06 pm
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
I'd take waiting a few years to get something worth downtown space rather than midrises filling our downtown...HskrFanMike wrote:The main reason Fahey chose the smaller Hilton was cost; the Hilton was originally bid at $60 million for the 400 rooms versus over $90 million for the 528 room Marriott. The redesigns to the Hilton pushed the final cost of the Hilton to $71 million for 450 rooms. Pretty tough to justify spending the extra $20 million to add 78 rooms...especially when the Hilton added twice as many rooms (150) ten years later at $37 million. (Still a lower cost per room, especially when you consider that the expansion was built with 2011 money instead of 2002 money.)
The only reason people are still upset about this is the obsession by some people for height... the same height obsession that resulted in the dumb selection of the Wall Street Tower boondoggle instead of a midrise office building. Nearly a dozen years later, all we have to show for it is the remnants of a wiffle ball field.
#gohawks
-
- Parks & Recreation
- Posts: 1219
- Joined: Tue Jun 21, 2005 12:40 pm
- Contact:
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
And wait...and wait...and wait...
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
I want high rises too, but I don't want a situation like Mobile, Alabama where there's like 1 awkward tall building and no-one has heard of your city. Height is important but the city can still have a great reputation.buildomaha wrote:I'd take waiting a few years to get something worth downtown space rather than midrises filling our downtown...HskrFanMike wrote:The main reason Fahey chose the smaller Hilton was cost; the Hilton was originally bid at $60 million for the 400 rooms versus over $90 million for the 528 room Marriott. The redesigns to the Hilton pushed the final cost of the Hilton to $71 million for 450 rooms. Pretty tough to justify spending the extra $20 million to add 78 rooms...especially when the Hilton added twice as many rooms (150) ten years later at $37 million. (Still a lower cost per room, especially when you consider that the expansion was built with 2011 money instead of 2002 money.)
The only reason people are still upset about this is the obsession by some people for height... the same height obsession that resulted in the dumb selection of the Wall Street Tower boondoggle instead of a midrise office building. Nearly a dozen years later, all we have to show for it is the remnants of a wiffle ball field.
- Coyote
- City Council
- Posts: 33088
- Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2003 11:18 am
- Location: Aksarben Village
- Contact:
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
Not too bad for a 200k city...:daveoma wrote: I want high rises too, but I don't want a situation like Mobile, Alabama where there's like 1 awkward tall building and no-one has heard of your city. Height is important but the city can still have a great reputation.
- damonhynes
- Parks & Recreation
- Posts: 1074
- Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 7:35 pm
- Location: North Springfield, Nebraska
- Contact:
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
MOB is on my short list for places to retire.Coyote wrote:Not too bad for a 200k city...:daveoma wrote: I want high rises too, but I don't want a situation like Mobile, Alabama where there's like 1 awkward tall building and no-one has heard of your city. Height is important but the city can still have a great reputation.
- nebugeater
- City Council
- Posts: 108923
- Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2004 6:07 pm
- Location: Gretna NE
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
damonhynes wrote:MOB is on my short list for places to retire.Coyote wrote:Not too bad for a 200k city...:daveoma wrote: I want high rises too, but I don't want a situation like Mobile, Alabama where there's like 1 awkward tall building and no-one has heard of your city. Height is important but the city can still have a great reputation.
Mall Of the Bluffs ?
For the record NEBUGEATER does not equal BUGEATER !!!!!!!
- damonhynes
- Parks & Recreation
- Posts: 1074
- Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 7:35 pm
- Location: North Springfield, Nebraska
- Contact:
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
LOFL!nebugeater wrote:damonhynes wrote:MOB is on my short list for places to retire.Coyote wrote:Not too bad for a 200k city...:daveoma wrote: I want high rises too, but I don't want a situation like Mobile, Alabama where there's like 1 awkward tall building and no-one has heard of your city. Height is important but the city can still have a great reputation.
Mall Of the Bluffs ?
I've got retirement narrowed down to Texoma, Mobile or Savannah. I'm in talks with the lottery commission...
- nebugeater
- City Council
- Posts: 108923
- Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2004 6:07 pm
- Location: Gretna NE
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
I knew what you meant but you tee'ed it up all to well. And if that lottery commission doesn't come through you can still say you meet your original plan and use this alternate as a backup plan.damonhynes wrote:LOFL!nebugeater wrote:damonhynes wrote:MOB is on my short list for places to retire.Coyote wrote:Not too bad for a 200k city...:daveoma wrote: I want high rises too, but I don't want a situation like Mobile, Alabama where there's like 1 awkward tall building and no-one has heard of your city. Height is important but the city can still have a great reputation.
Mall Of the Bluffs ?
I've got retirement narrowed down to Texoma, Mobile or Savannah. I'm in talks with the lottery commission...
For the record NEBUGEATER does not equal BUGEATER !!!!!!!
- damonhynes
- Parks & Recreation
- Posts: 1074
- Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 7:35 pm
- Location: North Springfield, Nebraska
- Contact:
Re: Never built Omaha Marriott Hotel
(snort!)nebugeater wrote:I knew what you meant but you tee'ed it up all to well. And if that lottery commission doesn't come through you can still say you meet your original plan and use this alternate as a backup plan.damonhynes wrote:LOFL!nebugeater wrote:damonhynes wrote:MOB is on my short list for places to retire.Coyote wrote:Not too bad for a 200k city...:daveoma wrote: I want high rises too, but I don't want a situation like Mobile, Alabama where there's like 1 awkward tall building and no-one has heard of your city. Height is important but the city can still have a great reputation.
Mall Of the Bluffs ?
I've got retirement narrowed down to Texoma, Mobile or Savannah. I'm in talks with the lottery commission...