More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

General discussion on all things Omaha.
eomaha
County Board
Posts: 4176
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:29 pm
Location: West Omaha

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by eomaha »

Kansas City Star wrote: Another lesson for KC

Less than five years ago, a nonprofit group in Omaha, Neb., was established with the goal of building a new performing arts center.

This fall, the $90 million Holland Performing Arts Center is scheduled to open on the site of what was once an ugly frozen-food factory that occupied prime real estate by a downtown park.

Another $10 million will be spent renovating the Orpheum Theater, a vaudeville palace much like the Midland Theater here.

The project was the fruit of a community fund-raising effort led by a board of civic leaders who raised $85 million in private donations. The city kicked in $15 million. The complex has a 2,000-seat concert hall that will be the home of the Omaha Symphony and a 450-seat hall for chamber music.

“The leadership of the community was very much behind the performing arts center,” said Joan Squires, president of the organization.

So why do I bring this up?

Well, it's been more than eight years since the Muriel McBrien Kauffman Foundation released a report saying that downtown Kansas City needed a new performing arts center. It was six years ago that the hillside site at 16th and Central streets was identified, and three years since the design for what was then described as a $304 million project was revealed.

After the flurry of excitement that accompanied the initial pledge of $105 million by Julia Irene Kauffman, the project's commander and chief patron, and the unveiling of architect Moshe Safdie's design for a 2,200-seat opera house and 1,800-seat orchestra hall, this important enterprise appears to be at least temporarily at a standstill.

The first indication that all was not going smoothly was in June 2003, when backers said they were contemplating scaling back the project to one multipurpose hall rather than two. A few months later, that idea was dropped and the two-hall concept returned, but with a smaller, 1,200-seat concert hall.

Then last May, Ken Dworak, the project manager, acknowledged the redesigns had pushed back the construction timetable from what was to have been a 2004 groundbreaking to August 2005 with completion in mid-2008. Fund raising also was going slowly, with $198 million in private pledges, but a professional fund raiser, Jeffrey Byrne, had been hired.

The latest setback was revealed last month. Sponsors said the failure of the Bistate II tax initiative, which was to have provided $50 million for the center, had forced them to rethink the project again. Safdie said a phased approach, building one of the halls first and possibly allotting some money to renovate the Lyric opera house, was being contemplated.

The fund-raising situation also had become less clear. Byrne was gone, and Dworak said donors had been told a project reassessment was occurring and they could reconsider their pledges. As for when the project might get under way — whatever its scale — nobody could say for sure. Safdie said a phasing plan would require months of additional design.

So, while Omaha is nearing the completion of a project that was only a concept in June 2000, Kansas City is still struggling to execute an idea that's been out there since December 1997.

In November 2003, R. Crosby Kemper III, at that time the chief executive of UMB Financial Corp., warned the board of the Economic Development Corp. that the community needed to focus on two major downtown projects, the headquarters of H&R Block, which is now under construction, and the performing arts center.

“We need to pick these projects and get them done,” Kemper said then. “If we lose them, it's a huge black eye to the city.”

Much has happened downtown since that June 2002 press conference when the design for the performing arts center was first revealed. Projects that weren't even being discussed then — the Block headquarters, the Kansas City Live entertainment district and Sprint Center arena — have been proposed, debated and begun.

The planned performing arts center is a vital addition to downtown, one that will complement the other investments currently under way. Besides providing a first-class new home for the performing arts, it also is necessary to attract the major touring Broadway shows that skip Kansas City because of its inadequate facilities.

It's becoming increasingly apparent that the project needs much more help from both the public and private leadership of Kansas City to come to fruition. Until then, the most up-to-date symphony hall in the region will be 180 miles north of here, in Omaha.
guy4omaha
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1280
Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2004 10:06 pm
Location: The Big O

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by guy4omaha »

At first I was really excited because I thought your headline was more MOAT material.

But nonetheless, ahh, the ability to gloat. Yes, I like it.
My old signature got too old. So old it was getting almost as old me as me. Yeah, it was up there in years.
almighty_tuna
City Council
Posts: 106419
Joined: Tue Apr 13, 2004 6:34 pm
Location: Somewhere between downtown and Colorado

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by almighty_tuna »

guy4omaha wrote:At first I was really excited because I thought your headline was more MOAT material.
No, THAT would be the Elkhorn River. :shock:
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

I was going to post this for you guys yesterday but knew somebody would find it quickly.

What the columnist fails to state is it's much harder to build a $300M+ facility than a $90M one. These great iconic buildings take time.
DMRyan
Human Relations
Posts: 644
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:07 am
Location: Des Moines, IA

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DMRyan »

It sounds like KC already has $105 million in the bank. If this doesn't get anywhere within the next few years, just let the interest build on $105 million and you'll have a considerably higher amount five years later. I'm sure the city will be able to rally around it to get it built, perhaps not quite on the grand scale of $300 million, but this development could certainly ride to coattails of everything else going on in downtown KC.
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

Approx. $205M has already been raised or promised through tax incentives. It's been the final $100M that has been tough to come by with the Nelson-Atkins sucking up much of the big time donor funds with it's $300M all private expansion currently underway.

It will get built, it's just going to take time. I'd rather do it right than fast.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

I love how that paper looks to Omaha and compares it to KC. Why Omaha? What about STL? We're getting more on par with bigger cities folks.
DTO
DMRyan
Human Relations
Posts: 644
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:07 am
Location: Des Moines, IA

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DMRyan »

With all the cutesy city boosterism and pride aside, KC is used to catching up to STL. When a smaller city manages to do something that KC hasn't yet, I think it sends a little more urgency through city leaders and development proponents. It's a natural reaction that most larger cities probably go through.

And yes, I think Omaha is defintely moving on to the next stage too. Make no mistakes about it though, it's no KC...yet.
CountOfMC
Library Board
Posts: 353
Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2004 2:24 am
Location: Downtown Milwaukee, Omaha

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by CountOfMC »

DTO Luv wrote:I love how that paper looks to Omaha and compares it to KC. Why Omaha? What about STL? We're getting more on par with bigger cities folks.
Because depending on how you read the article and articles of the past from The Star, the people of KC think, "well if Omaha can do it, KC should be able to do it bigger and 10x better." A little bit of snobbery, again, depending on how one reads it. And it wasn't so much this article, it's been articles of the past. Hey Kansas City, if you got questions, we've got answers.
God created alcohol to keep the Irish from taking over the world!
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

:(

Sorry you feel that way DTO. Just be proud of what Omaha is doing....no reason to compare. The reason this column was written citing Omaha is you guys currently have a PAC under construction while ours seems to be stalled in fundraising....so to kick ours in the |expletive| a bit. STL doesn't have a PAC under proposal or under construction.

If on par means building a $90M PAC instead of a $300M+ PAC, I guess you are on par. I tend to think they are 2 different classes of buildings. Kind of like a $200M arena AND convention center vs. a $250M arena.

I say, just be happy with what is going on without having to compare yourselves or ourselves with anybody else. We're all happy with what we've got....let's enjoy it.
User avatar
Admin
Law Enforcement
Posts: 1313
Joined: Sun Nov 09, 2003 3:36 am
Location: Omaha

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by Admin »

DTO post deleted for... well... excessive DTO'ness.
CountOfMC
Library Board
Posts: 353
Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2004 2:24 am
Location: Downtown Milwaukee, Omaha

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by CountOfMC »

KCPowercat wrote: Kind of like a $200M arena AND convention center vs. a $250M arena.
Kind of like a $300M arena and a $250M arena. :wink:
God created alcohol to keep the Irish from taking over the world!
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

Damn my... Oops. Darn my Howard Stern syndrome. I'm going to space. :) Thank you count for showing the real price. The convention center only cost $10 because that's how much it made. :wink:

I think we are on par with KC whether your PAC cost $300M and ours $90M. We both have one, they will do the same thing, and your paper felt the need to compare. Make no mistake, I do like KC (I even spent 2 weeks there to get away from my family) but Omaha is catching up and it's not so far beyond us as many Omahans think it is.
DTO
DMRyan
Human Relations
Posts: 644
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:07 am
Location: Des Moines, IA

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DMRyan »

Both of these cities are playing catch up to Des Moines, which built a PAC in the early 1980's. :wink: Too bad it looks like a Berlin bomb shelter though.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

You're right Ryan. 801 Grand is taller than 1KCP too so Omaha just had to do something better. :wink:
DTO
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

CountOfMC wrote:
KCPowercat wrote: Kind of like a $200M arena AND convention center vs. a $250M arena.
Kind of like a $300M arena and a $250M arena. :wink:
I did mistype I meant $300M arena and convention center. I was under the impression that the complex cost $300M for the arena and the attached CC.

So the arena cost $300M, what did the attached convention center cost ? If you really spent $300M on the arena by itself, I'd ask for about a $200M refund.
User avatar
Swift
Planning Board
Posts: 2887
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:13 pm
Location: NYC

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by Swift »

Yeah, though $190 mil for 2,000 more seats seems a bit suspicious. I hope they're solid gold! :wink:
User avatar
Swift
Planning Board
Posts: 2887
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:13 pm
Location: NYC

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by Swift »

Yeah, though $190 million for 2,000 more seats seems a bit suspicious. I hope they're solid gold! :wink:
Last edited by Swift on Wed Mar 02, 2005 9:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
DMRyan
Human Relations
Posts: 644
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:07 am
Location: Des Moines, IA

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DMRyan »

The MECA website says the Qwest Center (arena and convention hall) cost $291 million for construction of the facility, streets and utilities. Was acquisition and site cleanup a part of this figure too?
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

The whole thing, arena and convention center, was $291M. I don't know how much one cost compared to the other but I'm sure the arena was more than $200M. How much I can't say.
DTO
User avatar
Swift
Planning Board
Posts: 2887
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:13 pm
Location: NYC

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by Swift »

Don't belittle us. DTO is one crazy mofo, we might just send him down there to rough you up! :lol:
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

Yeah but even though the Ford Center has more seats it looks more like Kemper or the Civic. If it was a car it would be a Ford Taurus and the Qwest Center a Bently Continental GT ( Ilove that car). From what I saw of the Ford Center it didn't look like it had any suites or boxes and the outside looked like bricks with a glass window Actually it was jsut like a bigger Civic auditorium.
DTO
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

And the arena will end up costing more to becasue they probably are going to add the seats so we'll se how much those cost.

KCPowercat,

I heard the Sprint Center will seat between 18,500-20,000. What all will that include.
DTO
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

Swift wrote:Don't belittle us. DTO is one crazy mofo, we might just send him down there to rough you up! :lol:
Wasn't attempting to...sorry if it came off that way.


DTO....not sure on the old sprint center for numbers. The # of seats has little to do with cost of the facility. Amenities are most of it. I haven't been to Ford or Qwest so I can't say for certain either way....I was just going by costs. The convention center portion of Qwest would be a majority of the funds spent if you ask me but heck I have no idea....if anything 50/50. Is the Qwest even NBA or NHL approved for amenities? I know Ford Center is.

Sorry, this got off track...I was bored at work today and messing with DTO is fun.
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

CountOfMC wrote:I don't know the cost break-downs, but what's most impressive about the Qwest Center, in my opinion, is the outside appearance and I think the KC arena will be hard-pressed to out-do it. I haven't seen many pics of the Ford Center.. but can you honestly say it's more impressive on the outside? Forget what's on the inside... an arena is an arena. What people are going to remember most is how it looked visually on the outside.
I highly disagree with that last part. An arena is successful by how well it's setup inside with sightlines, amenities, bowl setup, etc. The exterior is just the cover....not saying it's not awesome to have a great exterior for the rest of the urbanscape to enjoy but an arena is either a success or failure by what is in the inside....I've said this many times about the Sprint Center and was the biggest reason I didn't want Frank Gehry doing our arena...I thought he would screw up the bowl and interior of the arena.

That being said, I boring exterior is no good either. I would say Qwest on the exterior looks better than the Ford Center but the brick of the Ford really matches what they are trying to do in that district.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

I'm pretty sure the Qwest Center is approved for sure for the NBA. I went to the Minneapolism-Atlanta exhibition gmae when it was here. I don't know if that really means it's approved. I'm pretty sure it would be for NHL too since it was built mainly as a hockey arena.
DTO
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

I don't know either...I just hear that alot when they talk about our new arena...that it will be up to NBA/NHL standards....no idea what it means. I assume it's seat # and suite #.
CountOfMC
Library Board
Posts: 353
Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2004 2:24 am
Location: Downtown Milwaukee, Omaha

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by CountOfMC »

^Good point, but all financials aside, when I think of the QC, the picture of it comes to mind first.. not necessarily how good the beer was, or how big the scoreboard was, or all the other amenities that go along with it. People come for the atmosphere, the intensity... and everything else on the inside is just icing on the cake.
God created alcohol to keep the Irish from taking over the world!
DMRyan
Human Relations
Posts: 644
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:07 am
Location: Des Moines, IA

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DMRyan »

I like the look of the Qwest Center better than WFA or the Ford Center too. For two arenas that are essentially identical in features (until Omaha builds more seats), this is what sets the two facilities apart.

Actually, the proposed Tulsa arena looks better than all the midwest arenas I've seen so far, but they're already scaling back and tweaking the design. Which IMO is what KC will end up doing when it comes time to bid the project.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

Oklahoma City's Ford Center

Image

Image
DTO
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

ok this is getting way off topic but oh well..

the sprint center's design isn't even really decided yet. All pictures shown have been simple concepts of using a lot of glass. the architects are going in that direction but really nothing has been decided on yet.

I know...nobody cares.


Back to the Ford Center and what is more important interior/exterior...the reason I hear it was so bare bones on cost is because they skimped big time on the interior...suites, amenities such as width of walkways, # of restrooms/concessions, etc. not how the exterior is built.....that's why it's already considered something of a joke...or I've heard it compared to a modern day Kemper (which is 30 years old)
DMRyan
Human Relations
Posts: 644
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 2:07 am
Location: Des Moines, IA

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DMRyan »

Actually, I think a lot of us care about KC's arena design. I'm looking forward to see what they'll propose.

I'm just saying that for a while now, there was talk of KC's arena being a new dimension of sports venues with its inside/outside transparency and an architectual icon for KC. I'm thinking that this can't be done for $250 million unless they value engineer the interior. I would rather have a decent looking venue on the exterior, with one heck of a plush and accomodating interior. With any luck, KC will end up with both...but from two cities that are/have built arenas, don't be surprised when some of the frills get cut.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

Ignore that first one

OKC's Ford Center.

Image

Image

Us.

Image

Image

Ours wins. I guess I was wrong about the Ford Center not having suites.

Ryan,
That Tulsa arena is ok but it isn't all that great. I still like ours better.
DTO
Finn
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1387
Joined: Fri Mar 26, 2004 3:54 am
Location: DC

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by Finn »

Of course the amenities are nice and the site lines are important etc. But that stuff has become boiler plate. I agree a great exterior is what sets an arena/stadium apart and gives it a unique appeal. People like Camden Yards, Coors Field (and many new football staiums) for their brick and retro pedestrian-scale exterior. KC has a nice stadium with nice site lines and an outfield waterfall, but the exterior is drab and in a sea of parking! Baseball is different as each ballpark has different distances, backdrops, alleys, seat configuartion, etc. Arenas are pretty similar as far as interiors with the newest adding a new amenity or two.
GoWest
Home Owners Association
Posts: 223
Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 6:10 pm
Location: Omaha

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by GoWest »

KCPowercat wrote:
the sprint center's design isn't even really decided yet. All pictures shown have been simple concepts of using a lot of glass. the architects are going in that direction but really nothing has been decided on yet.

Any pictures I see of the Sprint Center look great. I hope they don't mess with it to much.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

I love when people from out of town see it. They love it. Even ones from bigger cities.
DTO
KCPowercat
Home Owners Association
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Oct 04, 2004 5:33 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by KCPowercat »

isn't that exterior shot of the convention center?

I agree it is well done on the outside....can't comment on the interior.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by DTO Luv »

It's still the Qwest Center. They are the only arena and convention center in the country that share one continous floor. I used to work there and I have seen when it opens up into one place. It's pretty cool.
DTO
guy4omaha
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1280
Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2004 10:06 pm
Location: The Big O

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by guy4omaha »

DTO Luv wrote:I love how that paper looks to Omaha and compares it to KC. Why Omaha? What about STL? We're getting more on par with bigger cities folks.
DTO I don't mean to pick on you by singling out your comments here but...I can't resist using this post as a small example of the type of comments a lot of us Omahans seem to make. Some on the forum question whether Omahans taken as a whole have an inferiority complex.

DTO is fiercely proud of Omaha and fiercely pro-Omaha, but yet he questions why the KC columnist would choose Omaha as a comparison. And then the statement we're getting more on par with bigger cities. The last statement says we have not been up to par and we're not up to par yet.

DTO is not alone in this type of thinking that I think makes us look like we think our city is inferior. I don't think we even realize it most of the time when we make these comments.

Why not compare to Omaha? We have a heck of a lot going on that I submit is making people in other cities think their cities are inferior.

As far as being up to par, we are not identical to other cities. There are places where we are weak and some other cities are strong. But we have our strengths too in our own way and we need not apologize.

Just my opinion and I probably state it far too often. But I still contend that we view our city more critically than many out of towners do. Now, out-of-town people who are uninformed have certainly taken many a pot shot at our city in front of me. But what the heck do you expect from someone uninformed, perhaps ignorant, or just a regular butt. We need not concern ourselves with the butts. The butts will always be here.
My old signature got too old. So old it was getting almost as old me as me. Yeah, it was up there in years.
StreetsOfOmaha
City Council
Posts: 6854
Joined: Sun Feb 08, 2004 10:46 pm

More gloat material... c/o the KC Star

Post by StreetsOfOmaha »

A 2,200-seat opera house and 1,800-seat orchestra hall???


Uh, waiter! I'll have what KC is having. Thanks so much.
"The right to have access to every building in the city by private motorcar in an age when everyone possesses such a vehicle is actually the right to destroy the city."
Lewis Mumford, The Highway and the City, 1963