All for the sake of National Security?

General discussion on all things Omaha.
User avatar
Coyote
City Council
Posts: 34365
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2003 5:18 pm
Yahoo Messenger: jestcoyote
Location: Aksarben Village

All for the sake of National Security?

Post by Coyote »

NWITimes.com wrote: Citizens must fight tyranny to preserve freedom

An open letter to the Department of Homeland Security and its Transportation Security Administration: The TSA declares it "has developed standardized security screening procedures for all airports. Therefore, you can expect that you will encounter essentially the same procedures at each airport you visit."

I doubt this claim. Note that my remarks are reserved, tolerant, and most respectful concerning an agency that can arbitrarily deny me almost anything, including my freedom, in the name of National Security.

Consider my trip last week: On Thursday I flew from Chicago-Midway to Omaha. I breezed through security. At the first check point, I presented my boarding pass and my drivers license. Zoom, I was on to check point two.

At this stop, I placed my hat, rain coat, suit jacket, cell phone, PDA, tie clip, change, computer, pen, wallet, keys, and shoes in a series of plastic buckets. I did not remove my belt with its metal buckle on the hope I could get through, despite several times being admonished at other airports that all belts had to be removed.

If you persist to defend your socked-feet from public view, you will be taken aside to be wanded, as TSA calls it. At this point your entire body is subjected to a metal detector.

Thus did I pass, shoeless, but with my trousers held in place by my belt, through security point number two in Chicago. There was no unpleasantness. In the past, I've had verbal encounters with TSA agents as they apply their powers with remarkable inconsistency.

On Friday, returning from Omaha, I moved right through check point one. But as I loaded the plastic buckets again, I was informed I had to show my boarding pass again.

"No problem," you say. "Just take out the boarding pass and show them."

But I go into orbit. The routine has changed. The boarding pass was not part of the process at this point in Chicago yesterday, why is it required in Omaha today? I expect uniformity.

"Why do you have to see my boarding pass again?" I cry out in a voice louder than considered appropriate by the TSA agents. My presumed belligerence causes me to be wanded. I take offense since all I want is an explanation. They insist on treating me as a potential threat to national security, perhaps not a terrorist, but an unbalanced grandfather.

At this point I make a mistake. Uncharacteristically, I use indiscreet words to describe the relationships between the nearest TSA agent and each of his parents. Now several TSA agents are about me, visually assessing my danger index potential while one calls the airport police. To all I try to explain my distress: inconsistency. All respond that Omaha is Omaha, Chicago is Chicago.

Answers, if any, I am told, could be obtained from TSAs website or from TSA by e-mail. I apologize for suggesting improprieties in the relationship between the TSA agent and his mother and the legal status of his parents at the time of his conception. I am released from detention. Yet, all this time, not one TSA agent asks to see my boarding pass, the object of my objection.

We need an extensive review of security measures at airports by an agency outside of the Department of Homeland Security. Are we overdoing oversight? Do we give efficiency sufficient attention as we seek security? Do we allow citizens the freedom to ask questions in the airport? Today, if you do, you will have to step out of line like a noisy, naughty kindergartner.
edsas
Human Relations
Posts: 841
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2004 3:47 am
Location: La Vista

All for the sake of National Security?

Post by edsas »

I think standardized checkpoints is a good idea. But his belligerence was kind of weird. The airports I've flown in and out of since 9/11 include LAX, Burbank, Ontario, DIA, DFW, Tampa International. All airports had slightly different standards and methods and, while uniformity would be nice, a hassle is still a hassle. After flying the last two years with a 2 year-old, lugging his carseat and stroller through the checkpoints in addition to all the luggage, I really don't give a damn what order things are done. I just want to get on the plane.
TechnicalDisaster
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1649
Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 10:47 pm
Location: I got old...

All for the sake of National Security?

Post by TechnicalDisaster »

You know, I'm all about the preservation of rights, my posts about DTO's situation make that pretty clear. But, this isn't one of those situations. The TSA has about a hundred different questions they can ask a person at any given time. So this guy went through omaha a couple times, and one time they asked him a new question. So what? Asking to see a boarding pass at any time seems fair to me. So the writer beats around the bush with what he actually said back to the TSA to get pulled into detainment. What a joker. The real sad part of this story is that there are real rights that are getting violated everyday, but not to people who write for newspapers or whatever. I hope they put his name in a national database and give him sh*t everytime he tries to board a plane.
eomaha
County Board
Posts: 4176
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:29 pm
Location: West Omaha

All for the sake of National Security?

Post by eomaha »

The billions being spent to ensure a box cutter never makes it on another plane are a complete waste of resources. Americans will never sit complacently while another such 'hickjack' attempt is made (ie there's your line of defense) ... and more importantly the next act of terror will be nowhere near an airplane (at best it will be a shoulder fired missle launched safely from the ground ... but more likely it will be something entirely different we had never contemplated before). I think it's funny that my wife has given up two manicure scissors she has left in her carry-on cosmetic bag... but at the same time they've let enormous aerosol (hair stuff) cans potentially carrying flamable fluid go on. It's all just a big show... IMO.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

All for the sake of National Security?

Post by DTO Luv »

I know my grandma's sister was coming in from LA and they took an expensive diamond angel pin because of the needle on it. She was so upset because she was going to give it to my grandma for a Christmas present. She ended up buying her a new one and mailed it. It's ridiculous how many stupid laws they have about stuff now. I think it would be stupid to try and use a plain again. The next attack will probably be a chemical/biological one.
DTO
TechnicalDisaster
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1649
Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 10:47 pm
Location: I got old...

All for the sake of National Security?

Post by TechnicalDisaster »

It's funny you say that about the Aersol cans jeff. The last time I went throught the airport they confiscated my little tiny plastic bottle of lens cleaner. Said it could contain a flammable fluid. I guess you can't win them all...
icejammer
County Board
Posts: 3569
Joined: Tue Oct 05, 2004 4:39 pm
Location: Council Bluffs

All for the sake of National Security?

Post by icejammer »

Not to support the original letter writer in anyway (I think he was way out of line if he was being belligerent over a boarding pass), but it's been my experience with airports in CA, OR, WA, UT, CO, DC, and FL since 9/11 that the TSA agents in Omaha are the rudest ones of the bunch. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing for the job, it's just my observation (and one shared by several co-workers).