Cermak wrote: Sat Jan 12, 2019 1:22 pm
Oklahoma City has added two impressive office buildings in recent years Devon and BOK. Their skyline was looking sorta blah and now it has a fresh new look. Very few Midwest cities have added office high rises recently. Most new tall buildings have been Apartments or condo’s. Omaha’s best chance for adding height would be an apartment tower, similar to what Des Moines is doing. I’m hoping maybe First National will need another high rise at some point. Even a sharp 10-15 story building would be welcomed. For example Indianapolis has the Simon building DT which is 14 floors it would look great in DT Omaha.
I wonder what the relationship is between Oak City and Tulsa. I wonder if a huge ugly rivalry exists ? I like OKC chances better because it sits in the middle of the state and is the capital. I’ve never detected a huge rivalry between KC and St Louis. I think KC just try’s to make sure it has taller buildings than St Louis. But St Louis has the cardinals which most Missourians are crazy about. That’s probably the best thing about St Louis is the Cardinals, the stadium is right DT and it looks really nice. They get huge crowds and they are one of MLB’s marquee teams.
I've wondered that, too. But, I've generally felt the impression that Tulsa was an "aggressive little sister", that has more the "old money" in the state, always insecure they are the "second city" no matter what they do, no matter what taller skyscrapers they erect -- and with that taller skyline, all along they've had a beaming pride they had the better skyline. Still, even with the better skyline until recently, I was more drawn to Oklahoma City all along. It is centralized in the state, it is on the main crisscrossing interstate routes, it has more exciting & terrifying storms, and it just feels like western Albuquerque & Texas's glitzy Dallas-Fort Worth both beckon from there -- some even joke Okla City is a "suburb of Dallas." The original skyline was still likeable to me, a bunch of boxes suddenly standing tall together on the vast Plains - yet towers almost seeming slightly dusty, and not that inspirational. Now, I love the new tall, glassy, crystalline additions, that match the "spirit of the town" well. I also like how it sprawls kinda big in all directions from the downtown core.
One time, I drove from downtown on a main street straight north all the way until the city fizzled out north of suburban Edmonds. It really gave me a feel of the city and its "heartbeat" -- much like you would get if your drove Dodge St through all of Omaha, instead of passing through on I-80. Because the landscape is pretty flat and open, and the trees are not all that lush or tall, the city does have a duller, simpler feel & look -- yet there's more hints of SWern Spanish style architecture around here & there, and I do like that. The new housing is very uniform and uses a lot of brick & dark grey shingles, and some of the new, bigger houses are brick mixed with stone, and have nice warm design accents & shutters. Its definitely a tug-o-war transitional region (even more so than what Omaha deals with) where the West is meeting the East, and the North is fading into the South (not the tradtional South, but Texas).
This picture shows how the new simplistic, yet very sharp, crystal-like skyscrapers fit well into that semi-dull, central Oklahoma metropolis:
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/34/95/8f ... 3ea0ef.jpg
You can see the simpler & plainer aspect of Okla City here (even more so plainer than Omaha):
https://s8.postimg.cc/5vupfxdh1/OKC_skyline.jpg (I'm drawn to that plain aspect somehow.)
Great view of the newcomers to the skyline:
I love that lush green park with those regional fluffy evergreens -- likely either planted loblolly pines or bald cypresses from researching it -- next to those amazing new OK buildings:
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/TT1eyTqYC-M/maxresdefault.jpg
(Perfect fit for Okla City, imo. Great job, people. Designers must feel the same things... That's the type of sharp & keen sensitivity I want within architects/designers in Omaha, and I feel some designers do have it -- but not all. Architecture should reflect the city. Yet, I acknowledge that is the type of architect I would be, if I were one, as I am very contextual-minded, and I "feel" the city I am in.
Architects like Phillip Johnson, on the other hand, have suddenly ushered a brand new building into a city that didn't necessarily reflect it at all, and it worked. Take the IDS Tower in Minneapolis.
http://images.skyscrapercenter.com/buil ... ll2_mg.jpg It has blue glass like Minnesota's many lakes, but other than that, I'm not sure how that black & blue building reflected Minneapolis at all when it was designed & constructed. Yet, it is now an icon & symbol & anchor within the much-loved Minneapolis skyline that has grown up around it, and in some ways, some of that skyline has been inspired by its use of blue glass and zigzags, leading to a current day skyline very suitable for an energetic & on-the-move & innovative city. Or, take Johnson's Republic Bank in Houston:
https://s3.amazonaws.com/hines-images/b ... es_web.jpg There is no reason a building with a three-tiered set of dutch gables should work in that modern, Gulf-side metropolis -- but it does somehow. I think its because dutch gables are, geometry-wise, simple & basic enough, like the ancient pyramids of Egypt, that they can't necessarily be entirely claimed by historic architecture only. Modern architecture should be able to freely use those basic shapes as well. Plenty of modern skyscrapers have a pyramid-shaped cap on the top, for example, and that pyramid shouldn't necessarily tie back to ancient Egypt. However, if you look close, that bank has ornate accents on it -- suggesting the Old World. Maybe it works because Houston is so new & modern, and hardly has a significant history, a city built on reclaimed swampland, that taking something very old & traditional, like dutch gables, and almost irreverently using them to create a statement that is unexpected & bold & flashy & modern, works there. Almost a sort of "joke" in a city that some people tease is a sort of "joke." Still analyzing it... And, of course, the odd & surprising TransAmerica Pyramid:
http://images.skyscrapercenter.com/buil ... dfield.jpg When it was proposed for San Francisco, it caused outrage -- understandably. People couldn't catch the architect's vision. However, it was built, and in today's time, it is now an iconic and very much loved piece of Googie architecture defining & accenting San Francisco. I can understand why it caused outrage way back, I understand why some people still don't like it, but I do think it is a perfect piece of architecture for California's quirky & eccentric & eclectic, flower child metropolis -- along with being a good design for earthquake country.)
ST LOUIS vs KANSAS CITY: Exactly. Both towns love baseball, but those Cardinals... I have to say I love snazzy Kansas City, but I also love how ole, big, solid St Louis seems unaffected by energetic Kansas City, almost like an attitude: "You might be prettier, and keep making yourself prettier... But, I dont care. I'm the legend 'St Louis' here. I might be more stagnant, but Im also more steeped in history than you. You like white collars & wine, I like blue collars & beer better. I will always have the more solid frame and the bigger muscles."

I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.