St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Kansas City, Denver, Minneapolis, and Coast to Coast
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

RockHarbor wrote: Mon Jun 25, 2018 6:14 pm I know what you mean about feeling disappointed with Downtown St Louis per its size -- especially comparing it to smaller Kansas City across the same state, which has an abrupt & taller skyline and hopping downtown. Many people have felt that. The thing about St Louis to me is that it seems to have some civic pride, but Im not sure it is quite in the way that Kansas City, Minneapolis, Seattle, Denver, ect., has it about their town. To me, the civic pride is more rooted in natives, wrapped up in the sports team franchises, the national monument of the Arch (making St Louis instantly recognizable in pictures across the country), the Mississippi River, the history -- not necessarily an impressive "sparkling skyline" they are so proud of. I dont know. Its not necessarily a pretentious, yuppie, new money, white collar, artsy-fartsy civic pride there, imo.
St. Louis City has a lot more civic pride than I was expecting and I think a lot of it comes as a response (retaliation?) to the suburbs and suburbanites who have kind of shunned the city. Similar to Chicago (which is oozing in city pride), the city's flag is absolutely everywhere, on bumper stickers, t-shirts, incorporated into the logos and branding of local businesses, etc. My favorite bumper sticker I've seen says "friends don't let friends live in Chesterfield," which is our pretentious, new money suburb.

Outside the city (and the first ring of suburbs), I feel like many believe the city is a black eye on a great collection of suburbs and try to avoid it, which I think is different from KC and Minneapolis where the core seems to be more embraced.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Mon Jun 25, 2018 7:08 pm
RockHarbor wrote: Mon Jun 25, 2018 6:14 pm I know what you mean about feeling disappointed with Downtown St Louis per its size -- especially comparing it to smaller Kansas City across the same state, which has an abrupt & taller skyline and hopping downtown. Many people have felt that. The thing about St Louis to me is that it seems to have some civic pride, but Im not sure it is quite in the way that Kansas City, Minneapolis, Seattle, Denver, ect., has it about their town. To me, the civic pride is more rooted in natives, wrapped up in the sports team franchises, the national monument of the Arch (making St Louis instantly recognizable in pictures across the country), the Mississippi River, the history -- not necessarily an impressive "sparkling skyline" they are so proud of. I dont know. Its not necessarily a pretentious, yuppie, new money, white collar, artsy-fartsy civic pride there, imo.
St. Louis City has a lot more civic pride than I was expecting and I think a lot of it comes as a response (retaliation?) to the suburbs and suburbanites who have kind of shunned the city. Similar to Chicago (which is oozing in city pride), the city's flag is absolutely everywhere, on bumper stickers, t-shirts, incorporated into the logos and branding of local businesses, etc. My favorite bumper sticker I've seen says "friends don't let friends live in Chesterfield," which is our pretentious, new money suburb.

Outside the city (and the first ring of suburbs), I feel like many believe the city is a black eye on a great collection of suburbs and try to avoid it, which I think is different from KC and Minneapolis where the core seems to be more embraced.
Exactly. Good way of saying it. Thats exactly how it feels there -- although I think its definitely better than it used to be years ago (with the fact that the city has "raised its chin" and fought back, snubbing the suburbs). Years ago, Saint Louis felt more like a "small Detroit" surrounded by nice suburbs -- the city probably feeling shunned & neglected. Now, it has an attitude of "Yes, we are the inner city, and yes we have problems. But, at least we have CHARACTER. We are not boring & cookie-cutter like you." Love it! Go St. Louis! Yes, Chicago has some of that, too. It shows: No matter how world class & spectacular a downtown is (like Chicago has), suburbanites can still snub the inner city. Its so silly, imo. What would the cookie cutter suburbs be without that main inner core? The city + the suburbs make a metro more attractive & interesting, imo -- not just the burbs. Yes, that dynamic isnt quite found in the Denvers, Minneapolises, Kansas Cities... I knew there was civic pride there, but I just knew it wasnt typical.
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Mon Jun 25, 2018 5:10 pm
RockHarbor wrote: Sun Jun 24, 2018 8:09 pm
PotatoeEatsFish wrote: Sun Jun 24, 2018 5:48 pm Downtown is a great example of how the 70s and 80s killed downtowns, also their airport sucks.
The city of Lindbergh's airport sucks? I realize some of it is old, but there is some architectural flair and sweeping lines there -- compared to Omaha's airport. I've only been in it once or twice though. (And, I realize it "sucks" compared to Denver or Chicago's sleek airport. I pay attention to airport design a lot.) So, I'm curious why it sucks in your view... Downtown St Louis is busy & vibrant during the work day, per what Ive noticed. So, it seems similar to Omaha in that way. They dont have an Old Market area that I can think of, though, but I remember eating at a Spaghetti Works restaurant down there somewhere...
I think downtown could stand to be more vibrant than it is for a city this size. Washington Ave is pretty solid and there's often people around the City Garden/Arch area but elsewhere never feels like the center of a major urban area with 3 million people. Like I never worry about rush hour down there because there isn't really one of any great significance.

I believe the area you are thinking of is Laclede's Landing, which is kind of like the Old Market in a way if the Old Market were screwed over by terrible planning decisions. They've tried so hard to make it a vibrant old town area, and it was going well for awhile, but anymore it feels a little faded. They're trying to revive it again, but we'll see how that goes. It's cut off from downtown by I-44 and confusing to get to by car. They need to bury I-44 or tear it out completely north of roughly the Eads bridge if it's really going to take off. They also need to sort out the parking situation. Literally about half the footprint of Laclede's Landing is parking.
By the way, I finally took the time & looked at that spaghetti restaurant on Google Maps. I see now: It is a little historic district, hemmed-in tightly by the river and interstate, just north of the Arch. I never saw that restaurant again after eating there. Its called the "Old Spaghetti Factory." No wonder I never saw it again -- it is such a little area with limited access. Back then, we didn't have Google or Google Maps to peg businesses and their location. I just ate there, and always kinda wondered where that exactly was at, anytime I was in Downtown St Louis.

By the way, I mentioned before: I felt that new, riverfront Four Seasons Hotel just "worked" for St Louis. I felt because the color streak has surprising geometry like the nearby Arch. Yet, I kept thinking subconsciously that it reminded me of something more -- but not sure quite what. I know now. It kind of gives a vague impression of a leaning J-shaped saxophone and/or a jazz music note to me. That feels sooo "St Louis." Smart designers there....to match the Arch, plus the local jazz culture (whether intentional or not). Wow..... Great job. Love stuff like that.

https://pnimg.net/w/articles/0/529/e123606a59.jpg

Speaking of the Four Seasons, I like seeing the rooftop luxury looking pool set against all the steel bridges, the Arch, the old brick, the river. Just a neat contrast. It is kind of the same way with Omaha's new Marriott's rooftop pool (although Downtown Omaha doesn't look as old & brick & steel as St. Louis). https://d3hfxk7rwdcpol.cloudfront.net/C ... _LARGE.jpg
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
obvious2677
Library Board
Posts: 278
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:43 am

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by obvious2677 »

TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Mon Jun 25, 2018 4:40 pm
obvious2677 wrote: Fri Jun 22, 2018 3:23 pm
TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Fri Jun 22, 2018 1:51 pm
RockHarbor wrote: Fri Jun 22, 2018 4:43 am TITOSBURRITOBARN: After getting carried away with Obvious2677 here, I was scrolling through the thread, and I want to say that I appreciate your input on St Louis. It sounds like you're in St Louis, when I thought you were in Chicago? Anyways, you & Obvious2267 have convinced me to give inner St Louis a closer look. I'm also not alarmed about exiting the freeway between the science museum & downtown anymore.
Thanks Rock. I was in Chicago but then life happened and I moved to St. Louis a little less than a year ago (got married to a girl from the area and got into graduate school in the area). We're going to be here at least five years and reevaluate from there.

It overlooks the Central West End from roughly Kingshighway and Lindell Avenue. I apologize if this was brought up already, but over the past twenty years, the Washington University Medical Center has invested in a redevelopment corporation to see that the neighborhoods adjacent to their campus (which this is one, their campus is to the right out of frame in this photo) stabilize and prosper. This is one of the first neighborhoods that they worked on and has perhaps been the most successful.

In the immediate foreground you can see two parking lots, the one on the right with darker asphalt than the one on the left. The one one the left has been torn out and construction has been progressing on this 386 ft. residential tower:

Elsewhere in the neighborhood, this apartment building, the Orion, set a St. Louis record when it sold to an investor for $300,000 per unit. Note the ground-floor Whole Foods.:

Across the street is this apartment building, The Euclid, which has been completed since I moved here and includes a Shake Shack on the ground floor:

Roughly a block north, they completed this building, Citizen Park, around the same time:

Most of the neighborhood's commercial areas look like this with old stately homes in between:
Hope you get out and experience everything there (my grad school education was filled with beer drinking - and if yours is the same way, there is a ton of awesome breweries [not Budweiser] there). Actually, Urban Chestnut is now for sale in Council Bluffs - which I'm ecstatic about - and Schlafly was sold in Little Rock (spent 3 months there last year).

Central West End was too fancy for me to live in - but had friends who lived there.
We're certainly trying to experience all the city has to offer. One of my favorite things that my wife and I share in common is a desire to explore different places to their fullest. Trips we take together are rarely relaxing and lazy for this reason. I think we both tend to surprise each other with cool, sort of off-the-beaten-path stuff we find.

Anyway, we're definitely beer drinkers - I think I kinda knew she was the one when the morning after the first time I spent the night at her place, she asked if I wanted to go on a brewery tour. We tried to get to every local brewery in the Chicago area and are now doing the same in St. Louis. My favorite has definitely become Urban Chestnut (and I'm glad to hear they have made it out to Council Bluffs) and I think her's is Schlafly. I'm a sucker for breweries that have unique themes or locations, so Earthbound has become a favorite too. I dunno if they were around when you lived here, but they located in an old firehouse (I think?) on Cherokee, which they restored, and built a second level that just kinda hangs from a system of chains in the giant ceiling space.

Central West End was too fancy for my wife as well. Oddly enough though the first neighborhood we agreed to focus on finding a house in was Lafayette Square because of the awesome architecture. That was until we visited in person and found that we didn't fit the demographic of old empty nesters. After that she was leaning towards a Tower Grove South whereas I preferred The Grove/Forest Park Southeast. I ended up winning out when we found a nearly perfect house a block off Manchester.
Shaved Duck should be in your neck of the woods - I loved that place when I lived there. Urban Chestnut's food is spectacular as well. I actually drove to CB this weekend and picked up three 4-packs. I'm bummed they don't have Winged Nut (my favorite), but they have Schnickelfritz and Zwickel - which are still decent beers.

I don't think Earthbound was there when I lived there. Schlafly's summer beers are better than their year-round offerings, but they don't offer bar beeds. Go hang out in the park and drink. Also - if you do the Bud tour - and pay the $35 - they actually have beers local beers that they sell elsewhere that are free during your tour that are not sold in STL.

If I can ask, what are you going to grad school for?
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

obvious2677 wrote: Tue Jun 26, 2018 3:23 am Shaved Duck should be in your neck of the woods - I loved that place when I lived there. Urban Chestnut's food is spectacular as well. I actually drove to CB this weekend and picked up three 4-packs. I'm bummed they don't have Winged Nut (my favorite), but they have Schnickelfritz and Zwickel - which are still decent beers.

I don't think Earthbound was there when I lived there. Schlafly's summer beers are better than their year-round offerings, but they don't offer bar beeds. Go hang out in the park and drink. Also - if you do the Bud tour - and pay the $35 - they actually have beers local beers that they sell elsewhere that are free during your tour that are not sold in STL.

If I can ask, what are you going to grad school for?
We'll have to do the Bud tour some day. We've been there for various events, like Oktoberfest - which wasn't the least bit authentic - and Brew Lights - which was ok - but not yet on a tour, at least not anytime recently.

So I'm actually doing my master's in urban planning and development at SLU, which was also my undergraduate degree. I've come to find this is a little unique so I should explain that while many planners with an undergraduate degree in planning tend to get a masters in public policy, urban design, architecture, landscape architecture, or something similar, I really had no interest in any of those, save for urban design which doesn't seem very useful without an architecture degree. So I'm focusing on facets of planning in my graduate program that I didn't in undergrad. In undergrad I mostly focused on transportation and a little bit of urban design whereas in graduate school I'm focusing on real estate development to try and create a rounded education.

Were you here for school or work?
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
obvious2677
Library Board
Posts: 278
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:43 am

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by obvious2677 »

TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Mon Jun 25, 2018 4:40 pm
obvious2677 wrote: Fri Jun 22, 2018 3:23 pm
TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Fri Jun 22, 2018 1:51 pm
RockHarbor wrote: Fri Jun 22, 2018 4:43 am TITOSBURRITOBARN: After getting carried away with Obvious2677 here, I was scrolling through the thread, and I want to say that I appreciate your input on St Louis. It sounds like you're in St Louis, when I thought you were in Chicago? Anyways, you & Obvious2267 have convinced me to give inner St Louis a closer look. I'm also not alarmed about exiting the freeway between the science museum & downtown anymore.
Thanks Rock. I was in Chicago but then life happened and I moved to St. Louis a little less than a year ago (got married to a girl from the area and got into graduate school in the area). We're going to be here at least five years and reevaluate from there.

It overlooks the Central West End from roughly Kingshighway and Lindell Avenue. I apologize if this was brought up already, but over the past twenty years, the Washington University Medical Center has invested in a redevelopment corporation to see that the neighborhoods adjacent to their campus (which this is one, their campus is to the right out of frame in this photo) stabilize and prosper. This is one of the first neighborhoods that they worked on and has perhaps been the most successful.

In the immediate foreground you can see two parking lots, the one on the right with darker asphalt than the one on the left. The one one the left has been torn out and construction has been progressing on this 386 ft. residential tower:

Elsewhere in the neighborhood, this apartment building, the Orion, set a St. Louis record when it sold to an investor for $300,000 per unit. Note the ground-floor Whole Foods.:

Across the street is this apartment building, The Euclid, which has been completed since I moved here and includes a Shake Shack on the ground floor:

Roughly a block north, they completed this building, Citizen Park, around the same time:

Most of the neighborhood's commercial areas look like this with old stately homes in between:
Hope you get out and experience everything there (my grad school education was filled with beer drinking - and if yours is the same way, there is a ton of awesome breweries [not Budweiser] there). Actually, Urban Chestnut is now for sale in Council Bluffs - which I'm ecstatic about - and Schlafly was sold in Little Rock (spent 3 months there last year).

Central West End was too fancy for me to live in - but had friends who lived there.
We're certainly trying to experience all the city has to offer. One of my favorite things that my wife and I share in common is a desire to explore different places to their fullest. Trips we take together are rarely relaxing and lazy for this reason. I think we both tend to surprise each other with cool, sort of off-the-beaten-path stuff we find.

Anyway, we're definitely beer drinkers - I think I kinda knew she was the one when the morning after the first time I spent the night at her place, she asked if I wanted to go on a brewery tour. We tried to get to every local brewery in the Chicago area and are now doing the same in St. Louis. My favorite has definitely become Urban Chestnut (and I'm glad to hear they have made it out to Council Bluffs) and I think her's is Schlafly. I'm a sucker for breweries that have unique themes or locations, so Earthbound has become a favorite too. I dunno if they were around when you lived here, but they located in an old firehouse (I think?) on Cherokee, which they restored, and built a second level that just kinda hangs from a system of chains in the giant ceiling space.

Central West End was too fancy for my wife as well. Oddly enough though the first neighborhood we agreed to focus on finding a house in was Lafayette Square because of the awesome architecture. That was until we visited in person and found that we didn't fit the demographic of old empty nesters. After that she was leaning towards a Tower Grove South whereas I preferred The Grove/Forest Park Southeast. I ended up winning out when we found a nearly perfect house a block off Manchester.
Been a while since I said much here... That brewery was not there when I lived there. All of those places are quite nice. Hope you enjoy it.

Got bored at work today and found their murder data by neighorhood.

My color coding...
0-1 murders, green
2 murders, yellow
3-5, burnt orange
6+, red.

With 205 total murders in 2017....
Red = 79 murders = 38.5% of total
Burnt Orange = 31 = 15.1%
Yellow = 14 = 6.8%
Green = 5 = 2.4%

Image

I never had any issue in any of the green or yellow areas - and frequented them (because I was forced to with my work and friends all being in those areas). Poverty/lower incomes and some other crime, but not anything that scared me. I avoided the red area for sure and never had a reason to go to the orange area.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Yep, that's exactly why I didn't get off that centralized freeway and go north back then. I just knew that "red zone" was there. It looks really bad in there off Interstate 70.

Thanks for posting that. There's just something about "St. Loui-y." I don't want to live there. It's not my favorite city. It isn't completely my personality. But, there's just something about it that's intriguing to me. It definitely has a "flavor" all its own. Something about all the red brick, the glassy modern office buildings, the Arch, the bridges, the stadiums, the big river, the history, the legend Mark Twain...
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
obvious2677
Library Board
Posts: 278
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:43 am

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by obvious2677 »

RockHarbor wrote: Thu Aug 30, 2018 12:56 am Yep, that's exactly why I didn't get off that centralized freeway and go north back then. I just knew that "red zone" was there. It looks really bad in there off Interstate 70.

Thanks for posting that. There's just something about "St. Loui-y." I don't want to live there. It's not my favorite city. It isn't completely my personality. But, there's just something about it that's intriguing to me. It definitely has a "flavor" all its own. Something about all the red brick, the glassy modern office buildings, the Arch, the bridges, the stadiums, the big river, the history, the legend Mark Twain...
Yeah - and I didn't map all the way out either, that's just the end of the city boundaries. I almost always got off I-70 at the 64 interchange near Wentzville.

There were some sketch parts south of the city too - north side of Carondolet / south side of Dutchtown / Mt Pleasant area.

Might look through more of the data later, if I'm not busy.
User avatar
iamjacobm
City Council
Posts: 10834
Joined: Sat Apr 10, 2010 11:52 am
Location: Chicago

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by iamjacobm »

Any talks of expanding the MetroLink? Was in STL very briefly and used it to get from the airport to downtown. Seemed pretty well used, but looked like a limited system.
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

iamjacobm wrote: Thu Sep 06, 2018 5:02 pm Any talks of expanding the MetroLink? Was in STL very briefly and used it to get from the airport to downtown. Seemed pretty well used, but looked like a limited system.
Yes, actually. There’s been research conducted into a north/south line that would help connect those on the low income north side to jobs elsewhere in the region. I don’t think any funding or approvals have gone forward though.

More east/west routes are unlikely anytime soon given that the suburbs have been largely resistant to the system.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

I have not been to St Louis in over 20 years. Before World War II it was one of the United States most prominent and largest cities. It seems to have fallen in prominence the last 50 yrs or so but is still an important city. Below are some impressive stats for St Louis.

Hosted an Olympics (one of the few U.S. cities to do so) Once had largest train Station in the world. Once had one of the largest office buildings in the world (Railway exchange building). Tallest National Monument (Arch) . Only Yankees have more World Series wins than Cardinals. Was headquarters and hub for TWA airlines once a major American airline. Was larger than Chicago till 1880 census. Even has a underground light rail train tunnel.

I get to Kansas City several times a year, but St Louis isn’t as close. I need to get over there soon and check it out.
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

Cermak wrote: Tue Dec 18, 2018 3:35 pm I have not been to St Louis in over 20 years. Before World War II it was one of the United States most prominent and largest cities. It seems to have fallen in prominence the last 50 yrs or so but is still an important city. Below are some impressive stats for St Louis.

Hosted an Olympics (one of the few U.S. cities to do so) Once had largest train Station in the world. Once had one of the largest office buildings in the world (Railway exchange building). Tallest National Monument (Arch) . Only Yankees have more World Series wins than Cardinals. Was headquarters and hub for TWA airlines once a major American airline. Was larger than Chicago till 1880 census. Even has a underground light rail train tunnel.

I get to Kansas City several times a year, but St Louis isn’t as close. I need to get over there soon and check it out.
Its fall from a more prominent status is unfortunate, but partly its own doing. It’s not been the most friendly to African Americans over the years and it’s a bit terriorial in that it helps to be from St. Louis to be successful here.

Their companies are terrible about not being taken over and/or moved elsewhere. AT&T used to be based here but the rumor goes that when a new CEO from Texas came in and a local country club wouldn’t let him join for some reason, he decided to move the hq to San Antonio.

TWA used to operate a big hub out of Lambert Airport until American bought them and, although they said they’d keep STL as a hub, they changed their mind. So maybe 20% of the airport has been mothballed. Southwest though has shifted some focus from Midway to St. Louis which has led to a reopening of some of the gates that were mothballed.

The Olympics were supposed to go to Chicago, but with the Worlds Fair going on at the same time, the city convinced Olympic officials to move it to St. Louis. It was hilariously one of the worst olympics ever. Google it.

Speaking of Chicago, it’s said that one of the reasons Chicago passed St. Louis in population was because the St. Louis riverboat industry was so resistant to the railroad, even going so far as to try to destroy the first railroad bridge. Chicago embraced the railroad as well as the water and grew from becoming a transit hub.

The Arch is nice, but the city conducted a Jobbers Canyon style demolition of some of the city’s oldest buildings to build it. Its design was picked from a choice of others that resulted from a competition. The runners up were pretty bland. Most of them were office buildings.

The city has a lot of great things going for it now than in recent decades, despite what the media may tell you, and it’s definitely a gorgeous city worth a visit, but It has a ways to go before it’s in a good place again.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
User avatar
damonhynes
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1282
Joined: Wed Aug 27, 2014 12:35 am
Location: Montgomery County, Texas

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by damonhynes »

I don't know if it 'has a lot going for it', but it seems to have found its sweet spot. I was born there, lived my first seven years there, had relatives living there until the last one died in 2012. I-70 and Kingshighway, repperzent!

Unless govt dollars are behind it, nothing is going in downtown anymore. When private industry thinks of St. Louis, they're thinking outside of I-270. But finally, it seems that STL has decided that living in Chicago's shadow isn't worth it anymore--it's nothing to aspire to.

The only civic agony in play lately is that WOW Air ditched their STL-KEF(Iceland) flights. STL wants a TATL flight soooo bad, preferably to London or Frankfurt, not Reykjavik. Widebody, not an A320 or B737. Like in the old dAAys.

Even the Cardinals have taken a psychic hit lately--The Cardinal Way is dead and gone, the players are mercenaries like every other team in MLB.
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

I saw on the internet the city’s largest office building is empty. Former AT&T building 40 floors built in the 1980’s. The city offered it to Amazon if they put their 2nd headquarters in it. Hope Omaha never has this type of problem. Pretty depressing. I was aware of Dallas having a big skyscraper empty as well, but it didn’t seem to be that big a deal since they are growing like crazy anyway. But for St Louis or any other slow growth city you don’t want a 40 story empty building downtown if possible.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Cermak wrote: Wed Jan 09, 2019 9:57 pm I saw on the internet the city’s largest office building is empty. Former AT&T building 40 floors built in the 1980’s. The city offered it to Amazon if they put their 2nd headquarters in it. Hope Omaha never has this type of problem. Pretty depressing. I was aware of Dallas having a big skyscraper empty as well, but it didn’t seem to be that big a deal since they are growing like crazy anyway. But for St Louis or any other slow growth city you don’t want a 40 story empty building downtown if possible.
Really? I just took these pics of it just several years back with the AT&T logo at the top. Is AT&T shrinking? It is not "noteworthy architecture", but I still like the hefty skyscraper, especially from the front side, which is the broad side. Fat & wide & chunky, with big square windows, the base has a stair-stepping progression that is echoed at the top. I just like it -- it is just nice, practical skyscraper design, a big solid, hefty building, the kind you want to be around when you go downtown. (I love Amazon. I hope they buy it. A girl at the post office verified to me that mail is slower, and part of it is because the mail is heavier because of all the Amazon purchases. One thing I recently got on there was a DVD Ive eyed for a long time: "Minneapolis St Paul: Hotter Than You Think." And, "Los Angeles Plays Itself." I love city documentaries. You find everything on there.) Poor St Louis. Im sick of it in Chicago's shadow. I really want the best for it. It is a great historic town w/ a lot of reasons to love it. Its citizens seem to "get it" in the way outsiders dont necessarily.


Image

Image
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

Yes AT&T is shrinking they left the building altogether. I think some of the jobs went to Texas ( should we not be surprised). Sometimes I wonder if Texas could come up to Omaha and say “we want that company, that and that thanks Omaha”. Pretty scary. Now St Louis is trying to find a way to fill the building at least partially, it’s really not even that old and it looks decent.

Buffalo’s tallest is also empty, although I heard it’s being converted to residential. Thank god for residential conversions or Omaha would have a bunch of empty buildings as well.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Cermak wrote: Thu Jan 10, 2019 7:03 pm Yes AT&T is shrinking they left the building altogether. I think some of the jobs went to Texas ( should we not be surprised). Sometimes I wonder if Texas could come up to Omaha and say “we want that company, that and that thanks Omaha”. Pretty scary. Now St Louis is trying to find a way to fill the building at least partially, it’s really not even that old and it looks decent.

Buffalo’s tallest is also empty, although I heard it’s being converted to residential. Thank god for residential conversions or Omaha would have a bunch of empty buildings as well.
Thanks for the info. It has kinda happened before, with Enron. But, Omaha carried on, and is bigger & stronger then ever... Almost a million! I also read an article on it. Can you believe the price dropped from 93 to 11 million?! What a steal... I wish Omaha had a standard, nice-looking building like that from the 80's, and was getting a new building like BOK's new building in Okla City. Have you seen it? It's like a sharp, high-tech, diagonaling slab of blue/green smokey glass. Just as I feel is best, and just as Im seeing take place, new Okla City modern skyscraper design is kept fairly simplistic & nonfancy, yet tasteful & sharp. I think Omaha is much the same way (although I feel we can get by with maybe a tad more flair -- just a little). https://www.stltoday.com/business/local ... fb2b3.html
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

No I haven’t seen new BOK tower in Oak City except on internet and google earth. It looks great. I have never warmed up to their tallest, it almost looks to big for the town, should be in Chicago or Dallas. Oklahoma City has a real “can do” spirit about it. I know Omaha watches Them closely and also looks at Indianapolis. Like we’ve said before Indianapolis and Oklahoma City have some similarities to Omaha except on a slightly bigger scale. I like how compact and dense DT Indy is, they really don’t have alot of tall buildings but the ones they have are well placed for maximum effect. And their new airport is really impressive, especially since it’s not even a hub.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Cermak wrote: Fri Jan 11, 2019 9:42 pm No I haven’t seen new BOK tower in Oak City except on internet and google earth. It looks great. I have never warmed up to their tallest, it almost looks to big for the town, should be in Chicago or Dallas. Oklahoma City has a real “can do” spirit about it. I know Omaha watches Them closely and also looks at Indianapolis. Like we’ve said before Indianapolis and Oklahoma City have some similarities to Omaha except on a slightly bigger scale. I like how compact and dense DT Indy is, they really don’t have alot of tall buildings but the ones they have are well placed for maximum effect. And their new airport is really impressive, especially since it’s not even a hub.
Personally, I loved the design instantly, but yes, I joked it was like a tall rocket standing, ready for takeoff, at Cape Canaveral. I do feel like the design was smart & appropriate for Okla City, a city that doesnt have to feel subject to always having a dull architecture destiny, yet still, I also feel architecture with too much pizzazz & flair doesnt feel quite right there either (to me). For example, I dont feel Okla City can pull off Dallas's flashy, sharply-pointed apex Fountain Place, but they can pull off their new BOK building well -- a building also with a diagonaling slab of glass, yet with a flat roof and not as flashy of a coat of glass skin. The new BOK building, almost the same height as their former tallest, is helping to balance out that "rocket skyscraper" unbalance better, imo. Thats why my excitement & interest is growing regarding Okla City. Architecture makes a huge difference to many -- to outsiders considering visiting or moving to a city, and to insiders considering or not to stick around the city. The "can do" spirit you mentioned: I know what you mean, as it isnt old & staunch, and almost has attitudes of nearby progressive & inspirational Texas cities to the south, but the city's image was hurt by the town's old & dull & unchanging skyline for many years, and it doesnt help it is in a very plain & blah region (a bit greener than Amarillo, but a similar blah look). In some ways, I feel nearby Dallas & Tulsa have been more aggressive go-getters, until Okla City finally had enough -- that sudden new "rocket" skyscraper indicating years of pent-up frustration. Lol. (JK...I dont know that for a fact.) GOOD for Okla City. It deserves Oklahoma's tallest and biggest skyline because of its population, and all the barrel-shaped, horrifying, mega-twisters it puts up with, ripping up Moore every decade, or so. INDIANAPOLIS: The city was mysterious to me for years, until I finally visited it several times, and went to the amazing Indy 500. Now, I feel I understand the town. It is a very nice city with a GREAT & very busy & cheerful downtown, and the suburbs are so green & pretty with very nice-looking, sharp housing. However, it's not a city people typically pick up and move to -- unless you're from that state, or your job transfers you there. Most cities are like that in the Midwest except Chicago and Minneapolis-St Paul, I would say... I would be embarrased to say: "I'm moving to Indianapolis...just because."
Last edited by RockHarbor on Sat Jan 12, 2019 2:00 am, edited 1 time in total.
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

I wish Omaha could get a building like the New BOK in OKC. It would look great DT. Even a slightly shorter version I would take. I think OKC’s economy is more diverse than Tulsa’s. Tulsa seems to have slowed in growth the past 20 yrs, before that it was booming. Their skyline is actually starting to look dated to me. I have never been there I need to go sometime. I’ve driven Through OKC a few times but never spent any time there.

Indianapolis seems like a great Midwest city. To me it’s sorta a smaller less flashy Minneapolis. It’s stuck somewhere between Minneapolis and Omaha. The city I think went through some hard times back in the 70’s and 80’s as a rust belt city and needed to reinvent itself. Which it has. Getting an NFL team also probably helped, Omaha won’t get one anytime soon, that’s fine. I thought Indy seemed to maybe have its act together a little more than KC even though they are about the same size. Indy is the capital and largest city in the state which we know makes getting things done easier. I like how it’s the King of the state, KC can’t say that. Indianapolis location is nice as well , its just a few hours drive to so many cities, KC is more isolated like Omaha and out on the hinterlands.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Cermak wrote: Sat Jan 12, 2019 1:57 am I wish Omaha could get a building like the New BOK in OKC. It would look great DT. Even a slightly shorter version I would take. I think OKC’s economy is more diverse than Tulsa’s. Tulsa seems to have slowed in growth the past 20 yrs, before that it was booming. Their skyline is actually starting to look dated to me. I have never been there I need to go sometime. I’ve driven Through OKC a few times but never spent any time there.

Indianapolis seems like a great Midwest city. To me it’s sorta a smaller less flashy Minneapolis. It’s stuck somewhere between Minneapolis and Omaha. The city I think went through some hard times back in the 70’s and 80’s as a rust belt city and needed to reinvent itself. Which it has. Getting an NFL team also probably helped, Omaha won’t get one anytime soon, that’s fine. I thought Indy seemed to maybe have its act together a little more than KC even though they are about the same size. Indy is the capital and largest city in the state which we know makes getting things done easier. I like how it’s the King of the state, KC can’t say that. Indianapolis location Is nice as well its just a few hours drive to so many cities, KC is more isolated like Omaha.
What's funny is I root for the Colts because of my "thing" with Indianapolis, and for the Cowboys (before family even moved there) because of the Dallas skyline and their new amazing stadium. I'm kinda over Indianapolis now -- I think because the mystery has faded. Yet, I would love any chance to visit. I also love their flat tabletop suburban yards & lush greenery. Trees & evergreens are really big & lush there. They have such stately, nicely designed houses -- old & new. It's almost set up like Kansas City with a giant, oblong freeway ring around it -- yet it's flat, it feels not as artful & colorful & snappy as Kansas City, and feels more lacking "city identity" (possibly the shadow of Chicago) in a flat transitional region of farms & fields & trees. Yet, it has the Indy 500 and the city has come a long ways in gaining identity. It was intriguing to me -- a city staked smack-dab in the middle of Indiana, with skyscrapers gathered around a circle in the city center, a fairly big population, many new housing developments, some striking & big suburban buildings along the north half of the interestate ring, including an odd tri-set of glass pyramids sometimes featured in architectural books. I actually drove there on time from Omaha to Mark Twain's home in Hannibal, MO to Springfield, IL (stopped & saw Abe Lincoln's birthplace) to Decatur, IL, then took a state highway all the way to Downtown Indianapolis from there. I really felt like I got a sense of that region & city better than taking the convenient interstate. BOK Building: Yes, I think Omaha needs more of that type architecture. Even though it is even more simplistic & square & basic than our glossy, blue glass, jagged-roofed Landmark Center, it is still sharper architecture, in much better taste & style to me, and I know way more widely accepted in architectural circles...
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

Oklahoma City has added two impressive office buildings in recent years Devon and BOK. Their skyline was looking sorta blah and now it has a fresh new look. Very few Midwest cities have added office high rises recently. Most new tall buildings have been Apartments or condo’s. Omaha’s best chance for adding height would be an apartment tower, similar to what Des Moines is doing. I’m hoping maybe First National will need another high rise at some point. Even a sharp 10-15 story building would be welcomed. For example Indianapolis has the Simon building DT which is 14 floors it would look great in DT Omaha.

I wonder what the relationship is between Oak City and Tulsa. I wonder if a huge ugly rivalry exists ? I like OKC chances better because it sits in the middle of the state and is the capital. I’ve never detected a huge rivalry between KC and St Louis. I think KC just try’s to make sure it has taller buildings than St Louis. But St Louis has the cardinals which most Missourians are crazy about. That’s probably the best thing about St Louis is the Cardinals, the stadium is right DT and it looks really nice. They get huge crowds and they are one of MLB’s marquee teams.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Cermak wrote: Sat Jan 12, 2019 1:22 pm Oklahoma City has added two impressive office buildings in recent years Devon and BOK. Their skyline was looking sorta blah and now it has a fresh new look. Very few Midwest cities have added office high rises recently. Most new tall buildings have been Apartments or condo’s. Omaha’s best chance for adding height would be an apartment tower, similar to what Des Moines is doing. I’m hoping maybe First National will need another high rise at some point. Even a sharp 10-15 story building would be welcomed. For example Indianapolis has the Simon building DT which is 14 floors it would look great in DT Omaha.

I wonder what the relationship is between Oak City and Tulsa. I wonder if a huge ugly rivalry exists ? I like OKC chances better because it sits in the middle of the state and is the capital. I’ve never detected a huge rivalry between KC and St Louis. I think KC just try’s to make sure it has taller buildings than St Louis. But St Louis has the cardinals which most Missourians are crazy about. That’s probably the best thing about St Louis is the Cardinals, the stadium is right DT and it looks really nice. They get huge crowds and they are one of MLB’s marquee teams.

I've wondered that, too. But, I've generally felt the impression that Tulsa was an "aggressive little sister", that has more the "old money" in the state, always insecure they are the "second city" no matter what they do, no matter what taller skyscrapers they erect -- and with that taller skyline, all along they've had a beaming pride they had the better skyline. Still, even with the better skyline until recently, I was more drawn to Oklahoma City all along. It is centralized in the state, it is on the main crisscrossing interstate routes, it has more exciting & terrifying storms, and it just feels like western Albuquerque & Texas's glitzy Dallas-Fort Worth both beckon from there -- some even joke Okla City is a "suburb of Dallas." The original skyline was still likeable to me, a bunch of boxes suddenly standing tall together on the vast Plains - yet towers almost seeming slightly dusty, and not that inspirational. Now, I love the new tall, glassy, crystalline additions, that match the "spirit of the town" well. I also like how it sprawls kinda big in all directions from the downtown core.

One time, I drove from downtown on a main street straight north all the way until the city fizzled out north of suburban Edmonds. It really gave me a feel of the city and its "heartbeat" -- much like you would get if your drove Dodge St through all of Omaha, instead of passing through on I-80. Because the landscape is pretty flat and open, and the trees are not all that lush or tall, the city does have a duller, simpler feel & look -- yet there's more hints of SWern Spanish style architecture around here & there, and I do like that. The new housing is very uniform and uses a lot of brick & dark grey shingles, and some of the new, bigger houses are brick mixed with stone, and have nice warm design accents & shutters. Its definitely a tug-o-war transitional region (even more so than what Omaha deals with) where the West is meeting the East, and the North is fading into the South (not the tradtional South, but Texas).

This picture shows how the new simplistic, yet very sharp, crystal-like skyscrapers fit well into that semi-dull, central Oklahoma metropolis: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/34/95/8f ... 3ea0ef.jpg

You can see the simpler & plainer aspect of Okla City here (even more so plainer than Omaha): https://s8.postimg.cc/5vupfxdh1/OKC_skyline.jpg (I'm drawn to that plain aspect somehow.)

Great view of the newcomers to the skyline:

I love that lush green park with those regional fluffy evergreens -- likely either planted loblolly pines or bald cypresses from researching it -- next to those amazing new OK buildings: https://i.ytimg.com/vi/TT1eyTqYC-M/maxresdefault.jpg

(Perfect fit for Okla City, imo. Great job, people. Designers must feel the same things... That's the type of sharp & keen sensitivity I want within architects/designers in Omaha, and I feel some designers do have it -- but not all. Architecture should reflect the city. Yet, I acknowledge that is the type of architect I would be, if I were one, as I am very contextual-minded, and I "feel" the city I am in.

Architects like Phillip Johnson, on the other hand, have suddenly ushered a brand new building into a city that didn't necessarily reflect it at all, and it worked. Take the IDS Tower in Minneapolis. http://images.skyscrapercenter.com/buil ... ll2_mg.jpg It has blue glass like Minnesota's many lakes, but other than that, I'm not sure how that black & blue building reflected Minneapolis at all when it was designed & constructed. Yet, it is now an icon & symbol & anchor within the much-loved Minneapolis skyline that has grown up around it, and in some ways, some of that skyline has been inspired by its use of blue glass and zigzags, leading to a current day skyline very suitable for an energetic & on-the-move & innovative city. Or, take Johnson's Republic Bank in Houston: https://s3.amazonaws.com/hines-images/b ... es_web.jpg There is no reason a building with a three-tiered set of dutch gables should work in that modern, Gulf-side metropolis -- but it does somehow. I think its because dutch gables are, geometry-wise, simple & basic enough, like the ancient pyramids of Egypt, that they can't necessarily be entirely claimed by historic architecture only. Modern architecture should be able to freely use those basic shapes as well. Plenty of modern skyscrapers have a pyramid-shaped cap on the top, for example, and that pyramid shouldn't necessarily tie back to ancient Egypt. However, if you look close, that bank has ornate accents on it -- suggesting the Old World. Maybe it works because Houston is so new & modern, and hardly has a significant history, a city built on reclaimed swampland, that taking something very old & traditional, like dutch gables, and almost irreverently using them to create a statement that is unexpected & bold & flashy & modern, works there. Almost a sort of "joke" in a city that some people tease is a sort of "joke." Still analyzing it... And, of course, the odd & surprising TransAmerica Pyramid: http://images.skyscrapercenter.com/buil ... dfield.jpg When it was proposed for San Francisco, it caused outrage -- understandably. People couldn't catch the architect's vision. However, it was built, and in today's time, it is now an iconic and very much loved piece of Googie architecture defining & accenting San Francisco. I can understand why it caused outrage way back, I understand why some people still don't like it, but I do think it is a perfect piece of architecture for California's quirky & eccentric & eclectic, flower child metropolis -- along with being a good design for earthquake country.)

ST LOUIS vs KANSAS CITY: Exactly. Both towns love baseball, but those Cardinals... I have to say I love snazzy Kansas City, but I also love how ole, big, solid St Louis seems unaffected by energetic Kansas City, almost like an attitude: "You might be prettier, and keep making yourself prettier... But, I dont care. I'm the legend 'St Louis' here. I might be more stagnant, but Im also more steeped in history than you. You like white collars & wine, I like blue collars & beer better. I will always have the more solid frame and the bigger muscles." :)
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Republic Bank Houston: Still analyzing why that works for Houston... I think it is mainly that "irreverent thing" I mentioned, that Vegas kind of does... It might also be the fact that dutch gables are common in Amsterdam, a low & watery city -- which Houston also is, being the "Bayou City." Also, his "Cash Register" building is iconic on the Denver skyline. Originally, it was designed for a Texas city, but Denver got it. It works in Denver, though. It reminds me of an old western cash register shape, plus the curves/lines on the top make me think of the 'D' in "Denver." However, he didnt design the tower that way with those things in mind -- I dont think. Whatever the case, architects like Philip Johnson show me that contextual architecture, although always a safe choice, isnt always the answer everytime, necessarily. However, architects need to be very careful with a "bolt from the blue" architectural statement in a city. I also wonder if since we are now passed that new opportunity for something entirely new, architects in the Postmodern era often sometimes took, having a sort of "blank slate" with just boxy skylines to work with back then, if some brand new statement from "out of nowhere" is even appropriate anymore (with the exception of this new era we are in where we see very abstract, ultra-modern buildings -- like we often see built in Beijing and other Chinese cities). Cities like NYC and Chicago, which are "architectural playgrounds", can sport that type of new architecture better than cities like Omaha, however. They dont compliment existing American skylines at all, many times. BACK TO SAINT LOUIS: I really want to see St Louis progess this next year. Not every city is meant to be a sparkly, glass, white collar city. Some cities need to have that cool blues & beer & brick edge to it, and St Louis is one of those cities -- like Memphis. I think it should continue to develop that aspect, and push it more, and maybe market it more. (Its kinda like I cant expect Omaha to have the cosmo & glamour aspect cities like Dallas have. Its not meant to be that...) Here's the view of St Louis I love:
Image
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

St. Louis is cool, we can’t always just admire cities with new glass skyscrapers and new stuff all over the place (like Austin) St. Louis seems fascinating. This place was a top ten city 100 years ago. Unbelievable. It’s so easy to forget that. And it’s a 7 hour drive from Omaha. I think if I had a day to explore Austin or St Louis I would take St Louis.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Cermak wrote: Wed Jan 16, 2019 5:41 am St. Louis is cool, we can’t always just admire cities with new glass skyscrapers and new stuff all over the place (like Austin) St. Louis seems fascinating. This place was a top ten city 100 years ago. Unbelievable. It’s so easy to forget that. And it’s a 7 hour drive from Omaha. I think if I had a day to explore Austin or St Louis I would take St Louis.
Logically, I think cities should never expect to be the same place as other cities -- and that gives variety to live, variety to visit. I think St Louis should celebrate what it is, and possibly keep building upon it -- not what it isnt. St Louis is the type of city some people want.
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

I was looking at downtown St Louis on Google earth. It really is interesting. They have only three 500 footers and the US Bank building which is 484 ft. A relatively low skyline when you consider the overall population of the metro. But DT looks dense with many pre-WWII brick buildings between 6-20 floors. Particularly to the west of the DT core. This forms a brick dominated urban landscape more commonly found in North Eastern cities . In some ways St Louis is a bit like older Chicago with all the brick it has, but on a smaller scale. I’m interested in how Downtown St Louis overall health is. Is the DT vibrant and lively, empty and dead or somewhere in between ? . To me this will determine its chances of filling up any empty buildings that exist and any future development that might occur. Could St. Louis ever expand its city limits like Omaha, Kansas City and Louisville has ? Would that help ? The city is choked by its suburbs. It’s an urban donut hole. How many more people can it lose?

The Arch still dominates the skyline. And is St Louis most famous symbol. I’ve never been inside the arch but have driven by it a few times. It’s impressive but has it helped Downtown ? What would Downtown be like without it?

I really don’t know much about St Louis, where as Kansas City I feel alot more familiar with . I’ve just watched It’s population decline for years and years and wondered how much more? It will soon drop under 300,000 people, most likely on the upcoming 2020 census. St Louis once had over 800,000 people as recently as 1950.
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Cermak wrote: Thu Jan 24, 2019 5:27 am I was looking at downtown St Louis on Google earth. It really is interesting. They have only three 500 footers and the US Bank building which is 484 ft. A relatively low skyline when you consider the overall population of the metro. But DT looks dense with many pre-WWII brick buildings between 6-20 floors. Particularly to the west of the DT core. This forms a brick dominated urban landscape more commonly found in North Eastern cities . In some ways St Louis is a bit like older Chicago with all the brick it has, but on a smaller scale. I’m interested in how Downtown St Louis overall health is. Is the DT vibrant and lively, empty and dead or somewhere in between ? . To me this will determine its chances of filling up any empty buildings that exist and any future development that might occur. Could St. Louis ever expand its city limits like Omaha, Kansas City and Louisville has ? Would that help ? The city is choked by its suburbs. It’s an urban donut hole. How many more people can it lose?

The Arch still dominates the skyline. And is St Louis most famous symbol. I’ve never been inside the arch but have driven by it a few times. It’s impressive but has it helped Downtown ? What would Downtown be like without it?

I really don’t know much about St Louis, where as Kansas City I feel alot more familiar with . I’ve just watched It’s population decline for years and years and wondered how much more? It will soon drop under 300,000 people, most likely on the upcoming 2020 census. St Louis once had over 800,000 people as recently as 1950.
Those are good questions. I have the same ones. Im looking forward to answers. Maybe TitosBurittosBarn can answer these? I always feel like the metro as a whole, including downtown, are all very nice. Yet, the two scary & "thorny" ghettos, the one north/northwest of downtown and the one across the river, are what give the area a "bad wrap." When my family moved there from Omaha, suddenly we were living in a much larger metro, where the suburbs pushed another 20-25 miles out, suburbs that werent directly connected to downtown, way bigger freeways and traffic, but an "unspoken rule" to not ever venture off the freeway, if driving downtown or into the inner city. It was "dark" feeling, compared to Omaha. Downtown itself and all the attractions are nice, though. I like Downtown St Louis. The narrow streets make it very compact and dense feeling.
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

RockHarbor wrote: Thu Jan 24, 2019 10:27 pm
Cermak wrote: Thu Jan 24, 2019 5:27 am I was looking at downtown St Louis on Google earth. It really is interesting. They have only three 500 footers and the US Bank building which is 484 ft. A relatively low skyline when you consider the overall population of the metro. But DT looks dense with many pre-WWII brick buildings between 6-20 floors. Particularly to the west of the DT core. This forms a brick dominated urban landscape more commonly found in North Eastern cities . In some ways St Louis is a bit like older Chicago with all the brick it has, but on a smaller scale. I’m interested in how Downtown St Louis overall health is. Is the DT vibrant and lively, empty and dead or somewhere in between ? . To me this will determine its chances of filling up any empty buildings that exist and any future development that might occur. Could St. Louis ever expand its city limits like Omaha, Kansas City and Louisville has ? Would that help ? The city is choked by its suburbs. It’s an urban donut hole. How many more people can it lose?

The Arch still dominates the skyline. And is St Louis most famous symbol. I’ve never been inside the arch but have driven by it a few times. It’s impressive but has it helped Downtown ? What would Downtown be like without it?

I really don’t know much about St Louis, where as Kansas City I feel alot more familiar with . I’ve just watched It’s population decline for years and years and wondered how much more? It will soon drop under 300,000 people, most likely on the upcoming 2020 census. St Louis once had over 800,000 people as recently as 1950.
Those are good questions. I have the same ones. Im looking forward to answers. Maybe TitosBurittosBarn can answer these? I always feel like the metro as a whole, including downtown, are all very nice. Yet, the two scary & "thorny" ghettos, the one north/northwest of downtown and the one across the river, are what give the area a "bad wrap." When my family moved there from Omaha, suddenly we were living in a much larger metro, where the suburbs pushed another 20-25 miles out, suburbs that werent directly connected to downtown, way bigger freeways and traffic, but an "unspoken rule" to not ever venture off the freeway, if driving downtown or into the inner city. It was "dark" feeling, compared to Omaha. Downtown itself and all the attractions are nice, though. I like Downtown St Louis. The narrow streets make it very compact and dense feeling.
Downtown is kind of a mix. The former AT&T building is 1 million square feet and completely vacant. The Rail Exchange building is about the same I think. So there's been significantly more business activity, even in the recent past. However, they've been fairly successful in attracting people to live down there with many former office buildings and warehouses converted to apartments and condos. This is most evident along Washington Avenue where the building stock is nearly perfect and they've invested a lot in streetscaping. The Cardinals and the Blues bring a lot of people down on game days and the Arch grounds and the attached City Garden park have recently been heavily updated to attract more people. Both have received a lot of praise and have appeared to be pretty successful. But in my experience, its not as lively of a downtown as it should be.

From what I've heard, there is not a strong market for new construction residential downtown, yet the Cardinals have heavily subsidized a new highrise apartment building that overlooks Busch stadium, as well as a hotel, to complement their Ballpark Village entertainment complex. For multiple reasons, downtown would be much less lively if not for the Cardinals.

Funny you should mention city boundary expansion because there has been a push recently by a private organization to merge the city with St. Louis County. This has been pushed before, but there seems to be a lot of confidence this go around and lot of high ranking officials on board with it. Mayors of the suburban St. Louis County communities are not though, mostly because their municipalities would probably cease to exist and they'd be out of the job (A bit of hypocrisy, in my opinion, coming from the Republican mayors who often work to reduce government). If the merge passes, which the entire state gets to vote on for some reason, the city would have roughly 1.3 million people and would encompass the vast majority of the most expensive properties in the region. It could also lead to roughly 80 municipalities ceasing to exist. But, from my experience with Missouri politics so far, sometimes politicians don't like to accept the choices of voters and often work to keep things we voted on from happening. There's also a strong suburban contingent who want nothing to do with the city.

Without the Arch, the city would likely have a lot of cool old buildings along the riverfront. Apparently this area was dilapidated when it was cleared for the Arch, but I don't believe they needed to clear all of the land that they did. The park that the Arch sits in is massive and I don't believe the vast majority is used too extensively. There's not a whole lot that its connected to nor that you can do with it, especially to the south. Whether or not it's helped downtown is up for debate. I have no idea. But it appears to be one of the only internationally recognized landmarks where you can rent an apartment adjacent to it with full picture window views and not pay a premium.

The population of the city will probably decrease a little more but I think we're nearing the point of bottoming out. Even with the decline, the number of people per square mile is still pretty solid at somewhere around 4,500. A net decline of lower income, lower skilled people is more than offsetting a net gain of higher income, higher skilled people, but the rate of the latter is solid and increasing I think. So demographics are headed in a positive direction. Unfortunately the region as a whole can't catch a solid break with job growth, so this ship turns slowly at the moment. There have been a handful of quite shocking neighborhood revitalizations though. In mine for example, people used to not bother with stopping at stop signs or traffic signals because the crime was so bad. Now multiple new apartment complexes offer 1-bedrooms for about $1,300/month.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
Cermak
Planning Board
Posts: 2353
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2018 7:02 pm

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by Cermak »

That’s good to hear the population is getting close to bottoming out. It’s hard to believe it was one of the biggest cities in the country from the 1850’s to 1950’s. Suburbanization and the decline of riverboats and passenger trains dealt it a huge blow. And the rise of Chicago, Detroit and the industrial Great Lakes region probably also hurt. As St Louis was seen as not really a northern or southern city. I guess Chicago and St Louis still have a rivalry. Even though Chicago has long surpassed it in size and importance.

They should at least explore expanding the city limits. Especially if it can save some money. Just think if Omaha stopped at 72nd st, I wonder what it’s population would be today if we didn’t annex ?
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

Cermak wrote: Fri Jan 25, 2019 6:26 pm That’s good to hear the population is getting close to bottoming out. It’s hard to believe it was one of the biggest cities in the country from the 1850’s to 1950’s. Suburbanization and the decline of riverboats and passenger trains dealt it a huge blow. And the rise of Chicago, Detroit and the industrial Great Lakes region probably also hurt. As St Louis was seen as not really a northern or southern city. I guess Chicago and St Louis still have a rivalry. Even though Chicago has long surpassed it in size and importance.

They should at least explore expanding the city limits. Especially if it can save some money. Just think if Omaha stopped at 72nd st, I wonder what it’s population would be today if we didn’t annex ?
And racism. We can't forget racism. It hit St. Louis pretty hard. Still does to a some degree.

It's said that one of the reasons Chicago passed St. Louis so effectively in population and significance is because the riverboat industry that helped St. Louis become one of the biggest cities in the country 150 years ago wasn't going to let the railroad industry intrude on their turf. They refused to allow a railroad bridge to be built between Illinois and Missouri for a number of years and even tried to bring down the one they finally did build. Chicago was much more receptive to the railroad and really capitalized on it and its greater flexibility in moving people and goods than what waterways can.

My fear in expanding the city limits to include the entirety of St. Louis County is that it will lead to a significantly higher polarization in politics that could have negative impacts on the inner city's goals to improve urbanism. If St. Louis could annex the first or second ring of suburbs we could obtain a lot of high value properties and businesses for the tax rolls as well as a high level of relatively urban-focused voters. But even then I'm not sure if there's even enough money to be gained to properly turn the city into a better functioning organization.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
User avatar
RockHarbor
Planning Board
Posts: 2083
Joined: Wed Mar 23, 2005 1:42 pm
Location: Silver State

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by RockHarbor »

Interesting... Im wondering how glitzy cities that have boxed-in, tight city limits -- like Minmeapolis & Miami -- have made it work? Part of me likes how St Louis is boxed in by a plethora of little burbs, like Chicago and Los Angeles is --- making a street map colorful & interesting. If you notice, all cities surrounded by mighty, impossible to beat Chicago -- Milwaukee, Indianapolis, St Louis -- have sort of suffered under its oppressive shadow. But, I do feel each city is "raising its chin" nowadays and finding & appreciating its own individualism -- especially Milwaukee currently. (I dont feel Omaha has suffered that way. I think because it beat nearby Sioux Falls & Topeka & Lincoln & Des Moines on some levels, it had its "name in lights" early on, and it was friendly with greater metropolis Kansas City -- not really competitive. It was too far away to be under Minneapolis's or Chicago's or Denver's shadow. Des Moines, on the other hand, almost feels like Minneapolis's "obedient little urban apprentice", and part of that means dissing Kansas City & St Louis, and never being total buds with Omaha, yet they are allowed to look up to Chicago. Thats my perception, accurate or not. Lol) Anyways, Im just trying to think of ways St Louis can totally thrive & fully bloom again. It has a certain style. It is not Chicago, it is not Dallas, Atlanta or Phoenix. It doesnt have to be -- it couldnt be if it tried. So, whats it do in an age where the Dallases and Atlantas and Phoenixes are booming? Big deal it has past era "glory days" that are over. Its best days just could be ahead... (Omaha has dealt with that, and doesnt cry & whine about it... It just keeps "rolling up its sleeves" and working hard and plugging ahead.) I think that region's river cities, such as Louisville and St Louis and Memphis, all kinda struggle in the same way, yet Louisville seems to have less heavy problems as St Louis, and Memphis has that cool "Elvis/Music city" thing going on. Yet, St Louis has a red brick town, beer & jazz & baseball American thing going on that is special & individualistic. No town does that combo better, imo. However, still, how does it grow its prestige & solve its weighty problems? I dont know... But, they will figure it out, I think, one step at a time, if they put enough minds together.
I can get pushed out because I'm "too much" for some. Then, an observer of me comes suddenly swooping in to "fill my shoes." People are always more accepting of the new one, because their feathers aren't truly ruffled by them. (Yawn) I can count on it every time.
obvious2677
Library Board
Posts: 278
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:43 am

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by obvious2677 »

One of the funniest things about STL. https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/cri ... 0fe7e.html

Had to ask several people why streets were blocked off around mid-town. They said it was a "safety" thing back in the day (80s/90s), but the area has changed.
obvious2677
Library Board
Posts: 278
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:43 am

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by obvious2677 »

This isn't new, but STL Midtown is getting a 400-acre redevelopment - https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/fb4427_0 ... 3caf07.pdf

Proposed development at Grand and Chouteau. Literally next door to the $500m hospital and ambulatory center. Wish this was there when I worked in STL (literally across the street from this).
Image
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

I'm hoping this will be a catalyst for further development in the area. As it stands right now the area is kind of an island surrounded by industrial properties and a couple low-density commercial properties. That said, I'm concerned about how successful this could be. It's not well oriented to the area around it and in a city where most neighborhoods are declining, there's stiff competition for tenants. Besides those who work or go to school at the medical center, I can't see too many others interested in living here for a long, long time.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
obvious2677
Library Board
Posts: 278
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:43 am

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by obvious2677 »

TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Mon Apr 01, 2019 7:29 pm I'm hoping this will be a catalyst for further development in the area. As it stands right now the area is kind of an island surrounded by industrial properties and a couple low-density commercial properties. That said, I'm concerned about how successful this could be. It's not well oriented to the area around it and in a city where most neighborhoods are declining, there's stiff competition for tenants. Besides those who work or go to school at the medical center, I can't see too many others interested in living here for a long, long time.
The industrial properties separating SLU (between Grand and Compton) are going away - part of the 400+ acre overall development plan for this area. I don't disagree with you on most people not planning to live there for a "long, long time" - but since this is an Omaha forum, you could look at the apartment swell around Creighton as a similar project. Though SLU has more on-campus housing, they have an abundance of students that'd jump on modern living closer to the med campus.

The bad thing is the rail lines. It would be amazing if they brought the entire area up to the same elevation as Grand and then built a lid over them with a park between.

Here's the redevelopment area
Image
User avatar
damonhynes
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1282
Joined: Wed Aug 27, 2014 12:35 am
Location: Montgomery County, Texas

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by damonhynes »

obvious2677 wrote: Wed Apr 03, 2019 12:20 pm

The bad thing is the rail lines. It would be amazing if they brought the entire area up to the same elevation as Grand and then built a lid over them with a park between.

Here's the redevelopment area
Image
That's UP's main line--no way that can be covered up. BNSF and TRRA send a lot over that line, too. Yeah, it's a blight, but STL is STL because of the railroads and so they just better hush up about them :-)
obvious2677
Library Board
Posts: 278
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2018 12:43 am

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by obvious2677 »

damonhynes wrote: Wed Apr 03, 2019 4:46 pm
obvious2677 wrote: Wed Apr 03, 2019 12:20 pm

The bad thing is the rail lines. It would be amazing if they brought the entire area up to the same elevation as Grand and then built a lid over them with a park between.

Here's the redevelopment area
Image
That's UP's main line--no way that can be covered up. BNSF and TRRA send a lot over that line, too. Yeah, it's a blight, but STL is STL because of the railroads and so they just better hush up about them :-)
What? A lid would be no different than a very wide bridge. It's not like the rail lines would go away... The bridge span length at Grand is about 225-foot. I'm guessing the UP right-of-way jogs slightly south, along with the tracks, at Theresa Ave - but it appears that the same 225-foot-length span would easily get over the MetroLink and UP tracks with no disruption. I'm guessing (without measuring) that Grand to Theresa is under 750 feet. You could construct pilings adjacent to both the north and south sides of the rail track then bring in girders and drop them down in between trains. Not that complex - but it'd likely be costly. Heck, if there's no cost, you could go both east and west - put a lid from Prospect to Theresa, that's about 1/4th of a mile.

FYI - They just put a 97-foot-wide, 274-foot-long lid over I-44 by the Arch.
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

obvious2677 wrote: Wed Apr 03, 2019 12:20 pm
TitosBuritoBarn wrote: Mon Apr 01, 2019 7:29 pm I'm hoping this will be a catalyst for further development in the area. As it stands right now the area is kind of an island surrounded by industrial properties and a couple low-density commercial properties. That said, I'm concerned about how successful this could be. It's not well oriented to the area around it and in a city where most neighborhoods are declining, there's stiff competition for tenants. Besides those who work or go to school at the medical center, I can't see too many others interested in living here for a long, long time.
The industrial properties separating SLU (between Grand and Compton) are going away - part of the 400+ acre overall development plan for this area. I don't disagree with you on most people not planning to live there for a "long, long time" - but since this is an Omaha forum, you could look at the apartment swell around Creighton as a similar project. Though SLU has more on-campus housing, they have an abundance of students that'd jump on modern living closer to the med campus.

The bad thing is the rail lines. It would be amazing if they brought the entire area up to the same elevation as Grand and then built a lid over them with a park between.

Here's the redevelopment area
Image
What I mean is that this will become a student ghetto with no one else interested in being there until they sort out the connectivity issues to surrounding neighborhoods. It's an example of just-add-water urbanism where developers throw down a large development with all the bells and whistles but don't fully consider the context of the surrounding neighborhood and how to play off of it. Don't get me wrong, I know why they're starting with this component of the redevelopment project. It's vacant and SLU's 353 wants to start with a centerpiece (add a second centerpiece after City Foundry?) to draw further interest in redeveloping the area. But I feel like they're setting themselves up for only mediocre success until properties closer to adjacent activity fill in. Personally I would have started with the properties between the tracks and Gratiot to complement the activity that currently exists at Grand and Forest Park Ave as well as the upcoming Armory property redevelopment south of Hwy 40. That area is reasonably walkable to both the medical campus and the Frost campus and softens the barrier the tracks create between the northern tip and southern portions of the 353. This in turn sets up the development in the rendering above to come out of the gates sprinting.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert
User avatar
TitosBuritoBarn
Planning Board
Posts: 3295
Joined: Tue Nov 09, 2004 1:08 am
Location: St. Louis

Re: St Louis,MO talk- Is is dangerous or not as bad as perceived/Arch height restrictions etc etc...

Post by TitosBuritoBarn »

obvious2677 wrote: Wed Apr 03, 2019 6:12 pm
damonhynes wrote: Wed Apr 03, 2019 4:46 pm
That's UP's main line--no way that can be covered up. BNSF and TRRA send a lot over that line, too. Yeah, it's a blight, but STL is STL because of the railroads and so they just better hush up about them :-)

FYI - They just put a 97-foot-wide, 274-foot-long lid over I-44 by the Arch.
Not to mention a BNSF line through the Arch grounds has several large lids over it which have existed as long as the Arch has. You can see the exposed portions of the line through the grounds in the picture below between the tree-lined walkways and the river.

Image
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert