What makes Suburbia?

West Omaha, Sarpy and Nebraska metro counties.
joeglow
Planning Board
Posts: 2645
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2005 12:04 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by joeglow »

Geez. What do we consider the suburbs around here? West of 24th? It is no longer 1940.
Last edited by joeglow on Thu Aug 17, 2006 2:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Swift
Planning Board
Posts: 2887
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:13 pm
Location: NYC

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Swift »

joeglow wrote:Geez. What do we consider the suburbs around here? West of 24th? It is no longer 1940.
Well it's less than a block from 72nd street, and I wouldn't exactly call it urban development.

In my mind, the cut off is 68th st.
User avatar
Big E
City Council
Posts: 8181
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 5:12 pm

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Big E »

Yeah, the giant mall on 72nd pretty much solidifies that area's status as a suburb in my mind. About the time you hit intersections without pedestrian crosswalks and 90+% vinyl siding, you're in the 'burbs.

Oh, that and the carjackings. ;)

-Big E
Stable genius.
User avatar
nebugeater
City Council
Posts: 111080
Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2004 11:07 pm
Location: Gretna NE

What makes Suburbia?

Post by nebugeater »

Big E wrote:
Oh, that and the carjackings. ;)

-Big E
AS oposed to what, The drive by's ?? :wink: :wink:
djc311
Planning Board
Posts: 2187
Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2004 4:44 am
Location: Omaha

What makes Suburbia?

Post by djc311 »

Hmmm, I guess we're getting started again on East vs. West? Well, I'd hate to see crime statistics from activities East of 72nd St. & West of it. Just for fun, we wouldn't even need to go north of Blondo nor South of Center.

It's very unfortunate that someone was carjacked on Harrison, no doubt. But, just ask your insurance agent what your rates would be if you moved West. Besides the age of the home being considered, our house costs 1/2 as much to insure out here as it did just East of Dundee, & that house was 1/2 the size.

Any other arguments???
:wink:
D
joeglow
Planning Board
Posts: 2645
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2005 12:04 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by joeglow »

I am not trying to start an east versus west. I just laugh because it appears people here try to invent their own definition of suburb, which is:

a : an outlying part of a city or town
b : a smaller community adjacent to or within commuting distance of a city
c plural : the residential area on the outskirts of a city or large town

Frankly, I don't consider Crossroads an outlying part of the city and I certainly do not consider it a smaller community outside the city.

Anyway, I just laugh at how the word suburb becomes "ANYTHING other than downtown or areas immediately surrounding it."
User avatar
Big E
City Council
Posts: 8181
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 5:12 pm

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Big E »

There's a dictionary definition and then a practical definition.

I base the name suburb more on functionality than anything, which I suppose fits into your "anything but downtown" definition. I know it's not technically accurate. But by the same token, if you use the dictionary definition, some day Village Point and Elkhorn will cease to be suburbs as we sprawl to Valley (it's closer than you think, folks). Do we consider LaVista and Papillion suburbs anymore? Benson?

If your community is built around the automobile, you're in the burbs.

-Big E
Stable genius.
User avatar
Coyote
City Council
Posts: 34365
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2003 5:18 pm
Yahoo Messenger: jestcoyote
Location: Aksarben Village

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Coyote »

The evolution of the of suburb has changed through time and now had given rise to the concept ot 'growth centers'. Redefining Urban and Suburban America: Evidence from Census 2000, Volume Three (Redefining Urban and Suburban America) As decentralization of population and economic activity continued in most metropolitan areas, once-suburban areas have transformed into new engines of metropolitan growth, or "boomburbs." At the same time, some traditional central cities have enjoyed a population renaissance, thanks to the appeal of "living downtown," often close to workplaces and entertainment.
joeglow
Planning Board
Posts: 2645
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2005 12:04 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by joeglow »

Big E wrote:There's a dictionary definition and then a practical definition.
-I agree. But then, this opens up a new can of worms. What happens when commerce moves outside of the traditional downtown area (see St. Louis)? Does "downtown" then shift to this new area? Or is downtown simply the oldest part of town by default?
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

What makes Suburbia?

Post by DTO Luv »

Usually the DT has a skyline. :roll:


I wouldn't consider 72nd and Dodge suburban. Maybe notasurban.
DTO
User avatar
Big E
City Council
Posts: 8181
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 5:12 pm

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Big E »

I think downtown is always downtown... doesn't mean it isn't a bombed out wasteland, though, or a red light district or whatever. "Downtown" just has historical implications to me.

Now, future perspectives may say otherwise if we see another Phoenix develop a hundred years from now. (Well, if someone ELSE sees this a hundred years from now.) I suppose I have to concede if "suburb" is evolving, "downtown" could change, too.

We could probably look to the major European cities for some clarification on this. It's hard to think about the 1000-year evolution of a culture from an American perspective. I'm not familiar enough with Europe to know how the centuries old areas are classified compared to the newer areas of those old cities. How do you treat Berlin? Rome? Heck, you could even look to the Baghdad's of the world.

-Big E
Last edited by Big E on Thu Aug 17, 2006 8:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Stable genius.
User avatar
Coyote
City Council
Posts: 34365
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2003 5:18 pm
Yahoo Messenger: jestcoyote
Location: Aksarben Village

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Coyote »

Yes - but Downtown and the 'Urban Center' (as opposed to Sub-Urban) may not be synonymous anymore. Can a city have several urban centers or growth centers that are not downtown but not sub-urban. What makes an area 'urban' as opposed to sub-urban. Instead of looking at the definition of suburb - the definition of urban is: belonging to a city or town, refined, polished. Characteristic of, constituting, or pertaining to, a city or town. So does this make the legally geographic boundaries of a city or town Urban and that outside the city limits sub-urban?
User avatar
Big E
City Council
Posts: 8181
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 5:12 pm

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Big E »

Coyote wrote:Instead of looking at the definition of suburb - the definition of urban is: belonging to a city or town, refined, polished.
nah... it just means sub-urbanites are sub-refined and sub-polished. ;)

I had a thought... think of the ConAgra campus. No one would say it isn't "downtown", but it's more suburban in function than most of suburbia. (No, I'm not starting a JC war here, either.)

-Big E
Stable genius.
User avatar
Coyote
City Council
Posts: 34365
Joined: Tue Nov 18, 2003 5:18 pm
Yahoo Messenger: jestcoyote
Location: Aksarben Village

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Coyote »

I decided to split this topic from the Taco Bell topic so please continue this thread here.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

What makes Suburbia?

Post by DTO Luv »

As it relates to urban and suburban Omaha (or what I call the good part and the ghetto) I tend to think of 90th street as being the spilt. It may see too far west but those areas are still a bit older (post WWII) and aren't as spread out.

I think it's a bit sketchy to say what's a suburb in Omaha. We don't really have a lot of them. If you look at a map of St. Louis, Minneapolis, or even Des Moines you'll see tons of other towns around the city. Look at Omaha and it's Omaha, Council Bluffs and the 3 big towns in Sarpy County. Our western end will always be open for Omaha to grab so even if it is a 'suburb' it's still the city of Omaha.

I've never heard someone from Omaha say," I live in the suburbs." They switch suburb for west Omaha or La Vista or Papillion. If you go further than that to places like Gretna or Waterloo (and apparently Elkhorn) they are small towns outside of the city.

But moving DT I guess I won't be seeing much of any suburbs. Oh wait I can see CB from my window. Damn! :)
DTO
joeglow
Planning Board
Posts: 2645
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2005 12:04 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by joeglow »

I live off of 138th and Harrison and have considered myself to be more of a suburb. However, I have always looked at about 84th to 90th as the cut off, as well. For instance, Westgate is a relatively old neighborhood that is west of the "core."
User avatar
Swift
Planning Board
Posts: 2887
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:13 pm
Location: NYC

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Swift »

While 72nd and dodge may not be "suburban" it's definitely "suburban oriented growth," which is why I put it in the suburban category.

I wasn't trying to start an argument about what is a suburb and what isn't. Of course technically nothing in the city limits of Omaha is a suburb.

But would you really call 180th and center urban? Most people wouldn't. 72nd and Dodge has more in common with 180th and center than it does with 40th and Farnam or 50th and Dodge.


Edit:

Also, I should ammend my comment to say that when your primary mode of transportation is on foot, your perspective completely changes (litterally, things you thought were small look big, etc.).
User avatar
w8ing
Human Relations
Posts: 674
Joined: Fri May 05, 2006 9:32 pm
Location: Twin Cities

What makes Suburbia?

Post by w8ing »

If your definition of the suburbs doesn't change as cities grow you will be one very funny old man (or woman) calling places that are 10-20 miles inside the city limits suburbs. Outlying areas is a fluid thing. Unless, of course, your city stops growing (GASP! I'm sure no one wants that!).

Suburbs are not static on any border, unless sprawl is no longer occuring (yeah right). Just my opinion. Your mileage may vary.
Harpoon
Human Relations
Posts: 556
Joined: Thu May 19, 2005 1:46 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Harpoon »

When you answer the question "Where do you live?" with a response of the name of your subdivision, you live in the "burbs". I would agree with DTO that urban can generally be referred to as pre WWII development and suburban everything that has happened since.
User avatar
Swift
Planning Board
Posts: 2887
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:13 pm
Location: NYC

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Swift »

I would agree with that definition with this slight amendment: suburbs are any area designed primarily for automobile use over pedestrian use.

That largely falls under the pre/post WWII definition, but more and more recently we're seeing developments like Rows at SOMA, etc. which defy that label.

Suburban style growth isn't really feasible with out the car.
joeglow
Planning Board
Posts: 2645
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2005 12:04 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by joeglow »

Harpoon wrote:When you answer the question "Where do you live?" with a response of the name of your subdivision, you live in the "burbs". I would agree with DTO that urban can generally be referred to as pre WWII development and suburban everything that has happened since.
Like Dundee, Field Club, etc?
loyalomahan
Library Board
Posts: 426
Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2005 2:37 pm

What makes Suburbia?

Post by loyalomahan »

Yeah, I don't buy that argument.

While probably not a correct measure, I tend to look at 'suburban' in terms of it's lower density of development/street planning. You definitely see a significant drop off in density beyond 72nd (or even sooner), and a much more widespread introduction of isolated subdivisions beyond 96th, complete with their little signs and two or three entrances (ex: Regency, Candlewood, Barrington Park, etc, etc, basically every new residential area since the 70's). It's the layout of these newer neighborhoods which preclude, for example, a straight line walk to a nearby grocery store. I have amenities which are closer to me in the burbs, than most have in their 'urban' setting, but I still have to walk around all sorts of curving streets and out a subdivision entrance to even get on the main street to get to them. To me, that is what makes 'suburban'.

As for sprawl, I think most people consider 'suburban' neighborhoods to be sprawl, which to most civic planners is not the case. Sprawl is really nothing more than leapfrogging entirely undeveloped land for development (where the Street of Dreams is, a perfect example, the many outlying subdivisions, which are themselves very 'dense' by the way, of Phoenix). For the most part, Omaha's 'suburban' development (in Douglas County at least, Sarpy is a different story) has been relatively contiguous. The focus merely needs to be on making these subdivisions integrated in with the surrounding business/retail districts. Just think how convenient it would be to walk from the Pacific Springs neighborhood, directly north on a street into Village Pointe (preferably not through a big parking lot). Instead, a resident must walk through the winding neighborhood streets to a subdivision exit on 168th, then up it to the edge of the retail center's parking lot. I think, eventually, developers/consumers, will re-discover this amazing 'phenomena', which we left behind in the inner city.
Last edited by loyalomahan on Fri Aug 18, 2006 2:32 pm, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Omaha Cowboy
The Don
Posts: 1013743
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2004 11:31 am
Location: West Omaha

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Omaha Cowboy »

What is suburbia for Omaha is an interesting question..We all may be a bit different on this..

But I've always drew a line north to south on 120th St and have considered this the line that defines the beginnings of 'suburbia' for Omaha/Douglas county..

In any case, carry on..

:) ..

..Ciao..LiO....Peace
Go Cowboys!
bellevue
New to the Neighborhood
Posts: 3
Joined: Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:55 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by bellevue »

Wow. I have to jump in .

First with a definition:

1. Suburbs are inhabited districts located either on the outer rim of a city or outside the official limits of a city (the term varies from country to country), or the outer elements of a conurbation.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suburban
2. a district, town, etc. on the outskirts of city. websters/new world

That being said, what area is considered a suburb changes over time.
Dundee, was developed as an Omaha suburb. The two grew together and Dundee is now part of the city and considered urban. Harlem was developed as a New Amsterdam( New York City) suburb is now part of the city and considered urban. Treme and Faubourg Marigny were developed as New Orleans suburbs but are now part of the city and considered urban. Uxbridge and Brixton were developed as London suburbs but are now part of the city and considered urban.

In the examples above the suburbs had there own business district before becoming part of the larger city. The areas continue to have there own busines districts, but downtown New York City is a geographical, and vibrant business area that remains. At the same time 125th St is the heart of Harlem. London city centre is a geographical and vibrant business area that remains. Brixton and Uxbridge have vibrant high streets as do the other boroughs of London.

New York City suburbs are in New Jersey, Connecticut, Upstate and Long Island New York. New Orleans suburbs are Meterie, north shore etc.

Paplillion is a town of it's own but depends upon Omaha for it's survival. If papillion wasn't as close to Omaha as it is it would not have the development it has. The same is true for Council Bluffs, Bellevue, and Lavista.

Close proximity does not always make one city a suburb of another. Examples are Dallas - Forth Worth, San Francisco-Oakland-San Jose.

Downtown is downtown, more geographical, and historical than the center of all business. The suburb is the outer fringes of a core city.

The design of suburbs changes overtime. When Harlem and Uxbridge where developed the automobile wasn't what it is today. So the villages were designed around commuter railroad lines and therefore resemble the core cities. Compare Harlem and Uxbridge designs to the those of Los Angeles suburs and you'll see the affect automobiles have on city design. Compton Ca. an L.A. suburb, was designed for the automobile but the area is urban. 120th and Dodge is designed for the automobile bu the area is urban.

So, where are Omaha suburbs: Geographically, Bennington, 156th and Fort, 168th and Dodge, 154th & Center, , the areas just ouside the city and the neighboring towns, Council Bluffs, Bellevue, Papillion, Lavista, Bennington, etc. Where are Omaha's high steets or business districts, Downtown, Cross Roads -to -Westroads, Dodge St 72nd to 104th, Oakview, 72nd St Mercy to I-80, and many more.
Harpoon
Human Relations
Posts: 556
Joined: Thu May 19, 2005 1:46 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Harpoon »

joeglow wrote:
Harpoon wrote:When you answer the question "Where do you live?" with a response of the name of your subdivision, you live in the "burbs". I would agree with DTO that urban can generally be referred to as pre WWII development and suburban everything that has happened since.
Like Dundee, Field Club, etc?
No joe, that isn't at all what I mean. What I was talking about were places with names like "Barrington", "Deer Creek", "Piney Meadows", "Hawthorne Woods", "Torrey Pines", "Ironhorse", you know...places that have to have a sign with a big boulder sitting next to it and some landscaping to let you know where you are and to help differentiate it from the identical subdivision next door that has it's own sign, rock, and landscaping. Dundee was once it's own jurisdiction, so that is pretty much a self-explanatory designation.
Harpoon
Human Relations
Posts: 556
Joined: Thu May 19, 2005 1:46 am

What makes Suburbia?

Post by Harpoon »

Cul-de-sacs are another dead giveaway of suburbia.