ProRail director in town to speak on future of Amtrak

General discussion on all things Omaha.
eomaha
County Board
Posts: 4176
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:29 pm
Location: West Omaha

ProRail director in town to speak on future of Amtrak

Post by eomaha »

Omaha World Herald wrote: Group pressing to keep Amtrak subsidized

A group that promotes travel by rail will use its annual meeting today to build support for continued federal funding for Amtrak.

President Bush's 2006 proposed budget includes no funds for Amtrak, which received $1.2 billion this year for operations and capital projects.

Instead, Bush proposed federal matching funds for state investment in tracks, stations and equipment. No federal funds would go toward operations.

"This is the first time any president since the founding of Amtrak in 1971 has recommended zero dollars," said Richard Schmeling, president of ProRail, a regional group of the National Association of Railroad Passengers.

The national organization's executive director, Ross Capon, will speak at ProRail's annual meeting today, along with representatives of Amtrak, Union Pacific Railroad and the Midwest High Speed Rail Association. The meeting will begin at 9 a.m. at Courtyard by Marriott, 101 S. 10th St.

Amtrak funding became the meeting's focus because the group believes the survival of intercity service is threatened, said Schmeling of Lincoln.

"The practical effect of zero dollars for Amtrak would be that the current nationwide passenger system would shut down."

Norman Y. Mineta, secretary of transportation, has said Bush's proposal isn't an attempt to kill Amtrak. Changing the method of funding, along with top-to-bottom reform, is intended to revive what Mineta described as a dying system.

"If I wanted to kill Amtrak, all I would have to do is stand back and watch it die," Mineta said during a speech in Charlotte, N.C. "But too many people across this country depend on rail service - and even more would if we put passenger rail on a solid foundation."

Thirty-four years of operating losses and $29 billion in taxpayer subsidies have made clear that the system is flawed, he said.

Annual federal subsidies more than doubled over the last four years but still weren't enough to keep maintenance up-to-date, Mineta said. Amtrak's infrastructure is deteriorating.

Marc Magliari, an Amtrak spokesman who will attend today's meeting, said Amtrak's routes have never been self-supporting, but expenses have been trimmed and ridership has reached record levels the last two years.

Amtrak's total ridership reached more than 25 million in the 2004 fiscal year, a 4.3 percent increase over 2003.

One of Amtrak's long-distance trains - the California Zephyr - runs through Nebraska and Iowa on its route between California and Chicago. Ridership for Nebraska's five stations increased 8.9 percent from 2003 to 2004, and increased 14.6 percent for Iowa's six stations.

"We were created to operate these routes because the freight railroads that owned the tracks said they were not self-supporting, in the days when hourly wages and diesel prices were a fraction of what they are today," Magliari said.

Stricter environmental requirements also have increased the cost of operating the system, he said.

Why should Amtrak have to support itself, Schmeling asked, when every other form of transportation is subsidized.

"We subsidize air travel heavily. We subsidize highway travel heavily. With barge traffic, the federal government builds dams and locks," he said.

". . . Why do we treat Amtrak differently?"


Probably because it threatens an otherwise broader use of gasoline.
DTO Luv
City Council
Posts: 9644
Joined: Sun Jun 06, 2004 9:22 pm

ProRail director in town to speak on future of Amtrak

Post by DTO Luv »

That could be a reason but their are only so many areas in the country where rail commuting is really big. It's probably like DT shopping. It would be nice but that's not the way people do things anymore. I can't believe they aren't spending any money on Amtrak.
DTO
User avatar
Asten
Human Relations
Posts: 689
Joined: Thu Dec 09, 2004 2:25 pm
Yahoo Messenger: [email protected]
Location: Physically: Chicagoland. Historically: Omaha

ProRail director in town to speak on future of Amtrak

Post by Asten »

DTO Luv wrote:That could be a reason but their are only so many areas in the country where rail commuting is really big. It's probably like DT shopping. It would be nice but that's not the way people do things anymore. I can't believe they aren't spending any money on Amtrak.
Well, I tend to believe, at least in certain corridors, there'd be plenty of ridership if only there were investment. Europe sees huge amounts of train ridership, but it's never a moneymaker. I for one would love a high speed Omaha<->Chicago line, and choose it over a flight a big chunk of the time.
User avatar
Big E
City Council
Posts: 8181
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 5:12 pm

ProRail director in town to speak on future of Amtrak

Post by Big E »

The biggest thing I'm dreading about the move back to Omaha (aside from the unabashed conservatism, which I expect you all to assuage!) is having to drive EVERYWHERE.

I can't tell you how relaxing it is to get on a train in Baltimore and be in Manhattan in 2:30 hours. Total travel time from my house to NYC is about 2:36 minutes.

Wouldn't some kind of maglev connecting Omaha and Mnpls/StP and Chicago and KC and maybe even Denver and St Louis be great? I don't see why there's any reason it couldn't be built parallel to the major interstates (80, 35, 94, etc).

I know it's just a pipe dream, but man would I be on that all the time.

Edit: Check this link:

http://goeurope.about.com/cs/maps/l/bl_euro_dist.htm

Travel times by rail around Europe, for reference.

-Big E
User avatar
Ingersoll1978
Library Board
Posts: 490
Joined: Sat May 22, 2004 10:27 pm
Location: Des Moines

ProRail director in town to speak on future of Amtrak

Post by Ingersoll1978 »

I would love to see a midwest rail system put in place. If its going to built, it should be the most advanced system in the world. Every other form of transportation in America is SUBSIDIZED, I don't see why this shouldn't be. With O'Hare being the midwest hub, instead of spending billions to expand, why not put it in fast train service. The stops on these lines should be major metropolitan areas only. People will drive to Airports from the smaller towns and cities, why not to a train? The line from Chicago to Omaha (or Lincoln) should be Chicago, Quad Cites, Iowa City/Cedar Rapids, Des Moines, Omaha, and Lincoln. But the real key here is speed. If it takes as long to drive as to take a train, people won't use it. That's the problem with Amtrack. It needs to be half way between flying and driving.