Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Share your photographs and videos taken from around the metro

Moderators: nebugeater, Omaha Cowboy, Brad, BRoss

User avatar
nebugeater
City Council
Posts: 110868
Joined: Wed Aug 04, 2004 6:07 pm
Location: Gretna NE

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by nebugeater »

Does anone use a Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel camera? If so what are your thoughts. I am looking at taking the next step up in digital from my Sony 3.1 point and shoot to somthing a little more in line with all my 35MM equipment that I find myself hardly using any more. Got a Cannon A1, AE1 Program and T50 and I have been happy with the older Canon film equipment.

I am not sure I want to lay out over $1,000 for a digital rebal but at the same time I do not what to spned the $$ for a PRo1 if it is a dog. Have read a buch of review on the web and overall seem positive but I can "trust" you guys here, right? :lol:

Any feedback would be apreaceated. Is this a camera anyone would consider buying used if one can be found or is this something that sould be purchased new only. I am familiar and line the Canon brand but I have not ruled out others similiar to this if the price / features are OK on other options. Just sort of get comfortable with a " name" and have started there and this seems to fit what I am currently lookig for.

Thanks in advance.
almighty_tuna
City Council
Posts: 106353
Joined: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:34 pm
Location: Somewhere between downtown and Colorado

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by almighty_tuna »

First off, if you're looking at over $1,000 for a Digital Rebel you are looking in the very wrong place! For ordering gear I generally stick with B&H Photo ( http://www.bhphotovideo.com ). I personally would not spend that much on a camera and have it NOT be an interchangable lens SLR. I have to specify that because some camera manufacturers produce Single Lens Reflex digital cameras which do not have the capability for interchangable lenses. In that price range I would go straight for the Rebel XT. The Nikon D70 is also a good entry level camera I've heard, but I'm not familiar with nor have used Nikons.
TechnicalDisaster
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1649
Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 4:47 pm
Location: I got old...

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by TechnicalDisaster »

Can you tell me, what are the types of things you typically shoot? People, Sports, Architecture, family, children, landscapes, etc?

Knowing how you want to use the tool, helps me reccomend the right tool for the job... :D
TechnicalDisaster
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1649
Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 4:47 pm
Location: I got old...

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by TechnicalDisaster »

The most important thing to note about Digital Point & Shoot cameras is their horrible inability to shoot decent low light pictures. Cramming more megapixels on a very tiny sensor makes a nice resolution picture at ISO 50 and 100, but completely unacceptable noise at ISO 400 and above. If you want/need a P&S (point & shoot) digital camera for low light work, stick to a camera that has around 5megapixels.

Secondly, P&S Digital cameras have horrible depth of field at pretty much any given focal length and distance. Do you like the shallow depth of field you get with film? If so, you can kiss it goodbye with a Digital P&S unless you are doing Macro Photography or most of your subjects are less then 4 feet from the front of the lens. The sensors are so small (typically 1/8 the size of a fim negative or smaller)

I read over the review of the Canon Pro 1 at dpreview.com and here are my likes and dislikes about it:
Likes
1. Shoots RAW
2. Fast F2.4 lens
3. Tilt LCD
4. Lithium Rechargeable batteries
5. Extremly good pictures at ISO 50

Dislikes
1. Extremly poor digital noise at ISO 400. Worst in it's class. This camera is not for low light photography at all.
2. Tripod mount is not centered under lens. This makes the camera unusable for Panoramas and Digital stictches.
3. Price ranged from $570 to $700. For that, spring for a Digital rebel.

I really think you will be disapointend moving from a film slr to this digital P&S. (My very first camera was a canon AE-1 Programable)

For $758.00 you can get the Older Digital Rebel 6mp with lens kit at http://www.buydig.com/shop/product.aspx ... DIGRBL1855
Or look into getting a used Canon 10D off of ebay.

There is always the Rebel XT with the 8mp sensor and a little better performance too.
almighty_tuna
City Council
Posts: 106353
Joined: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:34 pm
Location: Somewhere between downtown and Colorado

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by almighty_tuna »

bradley414 wrote: For $758.00 you can get the Older Digital Rebel 6mp with lens kit at http://www.buydig.com/shop/product.aspx ... DIGRBL1855
Or look into getting a used Canon 10D off of ebay.

There is always the Rebel XT with the 8mp sensor and a little better performance too.
Don't forget the disadvantage of the delay for the point & shoots. When you press the shutter button it is not near instantaneous as it is w/an slr. This goes for film and digital.

Shop around. The Rebel XT w/lens kit is only $120 more at B&H. I'm not trying to contradict Bradley in the least. Just know that you can get good/bad deals in various places.
TechnicalDisaster
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1649
Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 4:47 pm
Location: I got old...

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by TechnicalDisaster »

The full shutter release delay in the Pro 1 was .8 seconds, which is pretty good by P&S standards. My wifes Canon Digital Elf has a 3 second delay witout flash. :!:

No contradiction taken. My first Digital SLR was a Rebel, and I got 20X30 inch prints made from CROPPED pictures. If money was an issue, don't feel like you are settling for the original rebel, that camera is great! If money is no issue, I would look to the XT or my personal fav, the 20D.
Jet915
New to the Neighborhood
Posts: 35
Joined: Tue Sep 14, 2004 10:27 pm

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by Jet915 »

I just got the rebel xt last week and I love it so far. I had a old canon rebel II slr and wanted to go digital. The pictures are amazing. I bought the body WITH the camera lens caused I wanted to get a wide angle to attach it to and still use my other two lenses from my old slr. I got the rebel xt w/lens for 739 at dell.com. You need to get the coupon codes though which can be found at bensbargains.net. Good luck.

Jetson
User avatar
Swift
Planning Board
Posts: 2887
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 2:13 pm
Location: NYC

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by Swift »

bradley- I'm just curious if you shoot on film as well as digital?
TechnicalDisaster
Parks & Recreation
Posts: 1649
Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 4:47 pm
Location: I got old...

Canon PowerShot Pro1 8 Megapixel

Post by TechnicalDisaster »

Not anymore. My first Film camera was an AE-1 and my last was an Elan IIE (replaced by 7 series) which I sold on ebay. After the move to the 20D, I never picked up the film camera again. I must say though, My sigma 15-30mm on the full frame film camera was pretty awesome for landscapes and wide angle. Almost makes me want to buy the new 5D, but I just can't spend that kind of money yet.