ita wrote: Wed Apr 17, 2019 2:06 pm
The thing that stood out to me most is a couple problems METRO faces: 1) does increased ridership prompt more routes, or do they create more routes to increase ridership,
Yes ...though more so the latter. Often an increase in density + increase in routes and shorter headways are the best at increasing ridership. Nice, clean infrastructure with useful amenities (WiFi, snack shop) can be an attraction, though I'm not sure how much of one.
2) they are limited to city limits
Like, they can't go into unincorporated areas? I haven't heard that but that might be fine for now. Not many riders there.
and 3) a lot of Omaha is not pedestrian friendly.
This is true, though the places where bus lines will be the most viable typically are.
With a more substantial bus system in suburbia, it would give a large demographic, middle school/high school kids a way to get around and theoretically reduce the need for massive parking lots, particular at high schools. If kids were teenagers that could drive, I would rather pay the $55 bus pass for my kid than however much it costs in insurance and gas (and possibly another vehicle) [...] The last problem is something the City needs to work on in developing the suburbs.
I touched on this a bit already, but while such a system sounds great, the density and layout of suburbia is hardly conducive currently to transit outside of park-and-rides to much denser places. The transit infrastructure being available is as important as the land use being conducive to people willing to use it. To get to your final destination from the bus, you'll have to walk from the station. There's nothing fun about walking in big-box suburbia. It may not take that long, in the grand scheme of things but it's not mentally pleasing. And it's not a good use of time for the bus to try and reach the front door of every solid traffic generator. It would take forever to get anywhere.
In order for a suburban bus system to work, suburbia needs to be retrofitted. We can't build big box shopping centers anymore. We can't build suburbia with the car at the center. We can't subsidize the car anymore. Suburbia essentially needs to look like Dundee everywhere. Otherwise it's unsustainable and your target market becomes too focused on those who are car-less out of necessity - the disabled, elderly, and very low-income. The benefits of taking your expensive car instead of the bus outweigh any benefits the bus would have.
I say this from experience working with the bus system that serves suburban Chicago and the issues they have had growing ridership.
"Video game violence is not a new problem. Who could forget in the wake of SimCity how children everywhere took up urban planning." - Stephen Colbert