nebport5 wrote: Thu Oct 29, 2026 3:41 pm
While I don't doubt costs are a factor with turf vs. grass I recall the topic being discussed at a city council meeting a few months back and remediation was given as the primary reason for choosing turf. I'm not a remediation expert but could it be there are still extended risks after clean up? Or could there be additional costs? Understandably, putting a slab of concrete over contaminated soil mitigates risks. So it may not be just the cost of maintaining grass.
Ok. So, I'm not an expert on this by any means and take anything I say as just a start of your own research, but I worked for MECA from 2004-2009. I worked with some of the physical electronic signage and scoreboards. I sat in on meetings regarding construction which was everything between erecting the parking lot LED signs that were put up in around 2005 to the preliminary meetings on what became TD Ameritrade Park/Charles Schwab Field.
Every meeting regarding any physical construction always included discussion on "disturbance of the lead cap". Again, I'm no environmental engineer and my attention to this was always limited to "yes, we can do that." Or , "no, because it will be too costly to dig that deep."
But, the lead cap was always a factor, and a cost factor in everything we did.
Looking online, this is a much more expensive and involved process than just pouring cement over contaminated land. I simply asked google some questions on it and was told the following...
While asphalt or concrete can serve as the top layer of an engineered cap, "paving over" usually implies laying down standard driveway or parking lot asphalt directly on top of the ground. An engineered lead cap is a multi-layered, legally bound system designed specifically to permanently isolate toxic material, block water infiltration, and withstand environmental degradation.
I looked into what the Omaha lead cap includes and how far it reaches....
The lead cap encompasses a significant portion of the 800-acre downtown brownfield redevelopment zone along the Missouri River. Specifically, it sits directly underneath and around:
1. The Convention Center and Arena Footprint: The heavy concrete foundations, sprawling exhibition halls, and surrounding paved parking lots of the CHI Health Center serve as a functional "hard cap", locking down the soil underneath massive impermeable barriers.
2. Lewis & Clark Landing: Located immediately east of the convention center property along the riverfront, this park sits directly over the primary site of the old ASARCO factory smokestacks. The 6-foot deep geosynthetic clay cap heavily blankets this area.
3. The Surrounding "Lot B" and Riverfront Developments: The engineered cap extends through adjacent commercial lots, the Gallup riverfront campus, and infrastructure supporting the National Park Service regional headquarters.
Any time construction, expansion, or park renovations (like the addition of the Kiewit Luminarium or playground structures) happen on or next to the convention center property, developers must work under strict EPA and state environmental controls to ensure they do not dig deep enough to breach this protective barrier.
I would have to imagine that the land the new stadium sits on will be every bit as contaminated as Schwab and CHI along with the riverfront. Again, this is an AI answer, but I found it interesting...
An engineered lead cap relies on a multi-layer system to lock down contaminated dirt and block water filtration. Choosing synthetic turf over natural grass protects that system for several reasons:
• Preventing Water Infiltration: Natural grass surfaces require heavy, daily irrigation to maintain professional sports standards. Pumping thousands of gallons of water into a natural field risks accelerating lead leaching. It forces water downward through the subgrade and pushes toxic plumes into the water table.
• Avoiding Deep Root Systems: Natural turf grass requires deep aeration, drainage systems, and soil conditions that could interfere with a geosynthetic clay liner or plastic barrier.
• Zero Soil Excavation During Upkeep: Maintaining natural grass requires aggressive mowing, re-seeding, turf replacement, and ongoing physical digging. Every instance of digging introduces a risk of puncturing the underlying cap or kicking up toxic dust.
• A Sealed Barrier System: Synthetic turf acts as a predictable, structural "hard cap". Once laid over the geomembrane barrier, it isolates the lead-heavy dirt completely. It keeps the players, workers, and fans safely separated from the soil below.
Take this FWIW. But, your point is probably absolutely correct. But, again, could this be mitigated? I'd say absolutely as Schwab has a natural grass field. Anything can be done.....for a price.